by Karon Brandt
U.S. policy seems to be to provide health care for anybody that needs it. I see the emergency rooms constantly filled with people. Many can't afford to pay, but they receive treatment. By law, hospitals MUST care for those...read more
by JoanM
Living in the UK everyone is treated the same, rich or poor, smoker or non-smoker, obese or thin. So my reply is YES smokers and over weight eople should receive health care treatment. Until I retired I worked in a Heal...read more
Would you be pleased to have a physical infirmity and not be able to get professional help? Perhaps as a youngster you started smoking and became addicted. If you are locked into a smoking addiction that you cannot break o...read more
This question is really morbid. Of course smokers and overweight people should receive healthcare treatment. People who are overweight or smoke or both are often people who are very stressed. Not having healthcare coverag...read more
by Candy Jules
I'm going with the overweight issue first. Weight changes can come from many things, and most of these are not from over eating, or eating the wrong foods. If you will look at family genetics, you may see that most of the ...read more
by Ethel Smith
I understand the concerns that many people have about the hospital treatment received by smokers and overweight people, but feel that there is absolutely no question that these people should still receive treatments.Here a...read more
by M. L. Kiser
Doctors playing God, deciding who to treat and who not to treat based on such things as overweight, smoking and alcoholism. Well why not; after all, it's clear that many of them mistake themselves for God. As a victim o...read more
by Lorlyn
This kind of question disturbs me because people are living human beings and grant it so people do not always do as their doctor prescribes or instructs, but from my experience I have been to doctor's who do not listen to ...read more
by Renee Dawson
If one is to ask "should smokers and overweight people receive health care treatment". then one must ask if anyone should be offered health care based on what kind of illness they have. For instance, should one receive tr...read more
Should smokers, and/or overweight people get health care ? Why stop there ? Drinkers ? Drug takers ? Un safe sex practitioners ? In essence should people, who by a life style choice expose themselves to ill health get he...read more
This is an issue I first came across whilst studying Spanish Culture at A-Level, and now I hear talks of the same occurrence in the UK. The issue I am referring to is the recent bombshell dropped by the NHS about whethe...read more
by nickname
This question seems to be worded incorrectly. It must be. It must not have originated from an American... To answer it honestly, one must include all socially induced behavior issues. Some other ones that should be i...read more
Cast your vote!
Click for your side. Must be logged in.
Featured Partner
Presidential Climate Action Project (PCAP)
The Presidential Climate Action Project (PCAP) has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause....more