Where Knowledge Rules

US Politics:

US Elections

Debate_icon Get a Widget for this title

Do Obama's ideas signal new hope or are they the same old Democratic ideas in a different package?

Results so far:

Same old
58% 227 votes Total: 391 votes
New hope
42% 164 votes

Since 1932, when Franklin D. Roosevelt announced his "New Deal," the Democratic Party has stood for redistribution of power and wealth from "big business" to the workers. It signaled the beginning of the Democratic Party's liberal agenda, which included government control of the economy, control of prices, the expansion of welfare programs and the increased importance of unions. Amongst other social issues, the modern Democratic Party has added to their platform, environmentalism, abortion rights, embryonic stem cell research, a national government health care system, a higher minimum wage and a progressive tax system that places higher tax burdens on those that earn more money.

After one wades through all of the hope and change rhetoric, Senator Obama's positions are really no different than the rest of the Democratic Party. One only has to look at his voting record to see this. When he has bothered to vote (he has missed more than 38% of the votes during the current congressional session), he has voted with the rest of the Democratic Party nearly 97% of the time. For a candidate promoting change from the "politics of the old," and "new hope" for the citizens of this country, Senator Obama has done little but to toe the party line.

Barack Obama has differed from his party's positions on just one significant vote. In that one, he voted against a bill that provided funding to the troops for the war in Iraq, increased funding for hurricane relief to Gulf Coast residents, provided funding for increased port and mass transit security as well as increased funding for children's health care, mine safety research and youth violence protection activities. This vote, to be sure, is in direct contrast to the views of the Democratic Party. Ironically, the majority of the programs that were to receive funding are ones that he purports to support.

One of the significant votes that he skipped was a bill that implemented recommendations by the 9/11 commission for changes to the Homeland Security Act. Specifically, this bill included provisions for the inspection of all cargo traveling on passenger aircraft as well as grants to improve the ability of first responders to react to and prevent terrorist attacks. One can only wonder why Senator Obama did not feel the need to vote on these issues, considered crucial in the country's efforts to thwart terrorism.

There is very little difference between Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama in terms of their voting records. Like Senator Obama,


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Do Obama's ideas signal new hope or are they the same old Democratic ideas in a different package?

Same old
  • 1 of 17

    by Scotty Mack

    Since 1932, when Franklin D. Roosevelt announced his "New Deal," the Democratic Party has stood for redistribution of power

    read more

  • 2 of 17

    by Daniel Walch

    Barack Obama is a skilled politician and a true American success story. However, his politics are more George McGovern than

    read more

New hope
  • 1 of 9

    by Lakshmi Swami

    President Barrack Obama is a democrat with a new sense of urgency. His office has become the busiest official business centre.

    read more

  • 2 of 9

    by Duane Kuehn

    Barack Obama's ideas signal new hope; they are not a repackaging of the same old ideas of the Democrats. It would be better

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Do Obama's ideas signal new hope or are they the same old Democratic ideas in a different package??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA