Where Knowledge Rules

Arts & Humanities:

Philosophy

Get a Widget for this title

Questioning the possibility of cellular memory

It is poetic to believe that memories and personality exist within every fiber of our being. Ideas abound in movies and books about the essence of one person transferring to another with a body part - to both the comfort and detriment of the recipient. However, science offers a different explanation of what is known as 'cellular memory'.

The idea of a donor passing something to a transplant recipient appears to have begun making public appearances in the scientific literature in 2002, though the clinical anecdotes and fictional stories of such experiences have existed for much longer. Recent research found that the chemical characteristics of cells may be transferred from the donor to the recipient, which can cause tissue-dependent alterations. Overall, it is simply chemicals and their signals being retained in the cells, which ultimately alters the cellular environment of the recipient, causing a change. It is not, by any means, transferred consciousness. In this case, "memory" means something different.

Misunderstanding Terminology

Popularized in movies such as "The Eye", "Idle Hands", "Blink", "Return to Me", and "Body Parts", cellular memory is a speculative theory on the transference of properties from a donor to a recipient upon transplant. Much of the scientific research on the chemical compositions of cells has been misinterpreted and combined with psychological impressions to create the theory as it has been represented by Hollywood. An indication of this is that most of the material presented scientifically has been published in psychiatric journals, or in journals known to cater to the pseudosciences, fields that attempt to approach ideas scientifically but have no way to experiment and gain empirical evidence.

A popular argument by those who want the scientific establishment to accept cellular memory is the story of Claire Sylvia, who received a heart transplant in 1988 and went on to find the donor's family via a series of dreams and fateful encounters. A handful of other stories also circulate about recipient experiences brought on, seemingly, by their donated parts. The theory is that our cells contain information about our personality, likes, dislikes, and memories.

The problem is that human thought and personality is so complex that it does not reside in a single cell, but in the entirety of the organ known as the brain, and for speculative purposes, even beyond on a grander scale. What research has shown is that the chemical environment


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Questioning the possibility of cellular memory

  • 1 of 6

    by Lakish Campbell

    In the 2008 film "The Eye", Sydney Wells, a blind but skilled concert violinist, receives the gift of sight through corrective

    read more

  • 2 of 6

    by Sharon Ruth Hill

    Deja vu experiences, or the feeling that a new event has also happened in the past, can seem incredibly real and vivid but

    read more

  • 3 of 6

    by Jishi Santos

    Is it possible that with a heart or lung transplant and the cells that go from one person's body into another that the

    read more

  • 4 of 6

    by David Brown

    This is being answered by a non-scientist. Well, not the kind of scientist that could try and explain whether or not cellular

    read more

  • 5 of 6

    by Alicia M Prater PhD

    It is poetic to believe that memories and personality exist within every fiber of our being. Ideas abound in movies and

    read more

View All Articles on:
Questioning the possibility of cellular memory

Add your voice

Know something about Questioning the possibility of cellular memory?
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

Helium Debate

Cast your vote!

Can Russia form a stable democracy?

Click for your side.

91914

Featured Partner

Northwoods Wildlife Center

Northwoods Wildlife Center has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause. Browse Northwo...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA