Channel Button

There are 44 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #7 by Helium's members.

Debate_icon

Entertainment   >

Music (Other)

Which is better, vinyl records or CDs?

Results so far:

CD
73% 483 votes Total: 664 votes
Vinyl
27% 181 votes

We may reminisce nostalgically about vinyl records - if we are over 30 or so that is - but we all know CDs have a lot more going for them.

With vinyls we had to be so careful - don't drop them, scratch them, throw them, leave then in the sun or let them get too cold.

Nothing was worse than going to put your favorite album on and finding it had got scratched, warped, split or bent. The needle always found the minutest of scratches and jumped at the best part of the song. There was that special 'phhhwwittt!..' sound as the needle skated across to the middle (and caused another scratch).

That's another thing with vinyls -having to get the stylus. The vinyls played by a needle (in the stylus) going over grooves in the vinyl plastic on the surface of the album (or single). Stylus wore out quickly, were expensive and you had to buy the right one for your model of record player.
As a teenager, I used to try and keep using styluses even though they were wearing out - with more scratches as a result.
Lending vinyl albums was always a risk, as was borrowing them. There was always the fear that if you lent them they would come back scratched or if you borrowed, you would scratch someone else's album- the constant pressure!

CDs store easily - vinyls you have to store straight on their side - they cannot be stacked and take up a lot of room vertically.
CDs will take a lot more use (and abuse). They are hard to scratch, you can store them anywhere and you can even keep them out of the box with a good chance they will still play all right.

Cds store a lot more information than a vinyl record and so you can get more tracks on each one in a far smaller area.
The sound is clearer and the quality remains the same over longer period. Many albums lose quality with each play and even a slight bit of dust of a tiny scratch results in constant 'tic' as the needle finds it with each rotation.The Jam sang' Eton (tic) fles) - well , at least they did on my vinyl!

With vinyls, there was often danger of jogging the turn table while the record was playing. The needle would jump and often scratch the vinyl record but with CDs you do not have this risk.

Learn more about this author, Sammy Stein.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Which is better, vinyl records or CDs?

CD
  • 1 of 17

    by Ill Cosby

    Vinyl Versus CD This debate has caused great rifts between music lovers and it seems as if this debate will probab...read more

  • 2 of 17

    by Alice Jones

    Compact Discs produce a far better quality of sound reproduction than Vinyl records. I must concede that there is ...read more

Vinyl
  • 1 of 27

    by Stan Dyer

    When it comes to sound quality, storage capacity and portability, there is just no argument. CDs are more convenient...read more

  • 2 of 27

    by Shane Dayton

    Vinyl records are better than CDs, and this is being written by a man who was born in the cassette/CD age. My father...read more

Add your voice

Know something about Which is better, vinyl records or CDs??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

What is Helium? | User Guide | Community | Link to Helium | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA