Channel Button

There are 197 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #3 by Helium's members.

Debate_icon

Arts & Humanities   >

Poets & Poetry

Does the best poetry come from the heart or from the mind?

Results so far:

Heart
75% 1312 votes Total: 1761 votes
Mind
25% 449 votes

The act of writing a poem is very much one of mind. The act of experiencing a poem is a mixture of both which varies by individual reader and writer.

Writing a poem first requires inspiration, the sudden experiencing of the very basic need to write. What happens - at least with me (and I'm trying to hold this from becoming about how I do this or how I do that) - is that I suddenly get a hold of some approximation of an idea I want to write about. Sometimes I'll just be sitting here writing just to hear what words sound like together and then I'll strike what I think is an interesting phrase. But even in such an idle act the mind is thinking "does this sound good" "do these ideas connect" "what if I changed this to that." Then sometimes something fires up. And I'll admit that sometimes these initial inspirations have an element of mystery to them. I don't know exactly why or what "music" it is that makes certain words sound compelling when put together. I simply "know" what does, what doesn't, what probably will. I'm sure most great writers have some innate sense after long practice of what they can put together to create and make "real" that first heartfelt burst of inspiration.

So what about everything else the poem is after those first two lines and the closing line? And not just the final version but all the red pens and deletions, carat notations, ?s in the margins? What of that "recollection in tranquility" Wordsworth famously spoke of? "Re-collection". To collect again. Well if it had to be collected again, where was it scattered? A collection of...anything...is a loosely or tightly organized assortment of similar objects. It is the mind which collects, which recollects all those similar ideas, phrases that it sees out there scattered in the ether. It sees a shape, organizes it even if it does so along lines and patterns that it cannot define except from some innate knowing.

Even this "innate knowing" is experiential. The poet's ear comes from infinite hours of simple listening, thousands of hours of reading and not just reading but hearing the rhythms of the words. It helps to have super-literate and discerning pairs of xx and xy chromosomes as well. What it reads could be the most passionate poem of a breakup/love lost/love gained - the most sweeping Leo+Kate thing ever written. And yes the passion is there and it's definitely putting a stamp on the ole cerebrum, but the mind and the ear are also tuned in to something even further and deeper


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Does the best poetry come from the heart or from the mind?

Mind
  • 1 of 71

    by Neil Deo

    The MIND wins! Ever heard of having a message go straight to the heart? That can be dangerous; there is no evaluat...read more

  • 2 of 71

    by Bethany Anderson

    Even William Shakespeare recognised how terrible poetry can be when it comes straight from the heart. His sonnets are...read more

Heart
  • 1 of 126

    by George F Pecoraro

    Before I go into the reasons why I believe the "Best" poetry comes from the heart, I cannot in good conscience let g...read more

  • by Don MacIver

    Speaking from a published writer's perspective there are realistically two dimensions to a poem's origins. A poem's c...read more

Add your voice

Know something about Does the best poetry come from the heart or from the mind??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

What is Helium? | User Guide | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA