Channel Button

There are 95 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #3 by Helium's members.

Debate_icon

Health & Fitness   >

Aging & Longevity

Get a Widget for this title

Should elderly patients be cared for by family members or by health care professionals?

Results so far:

Pros
42% 474 votes Total: 1118 votes
Family
58% 644 votes

Having worked as a Business Office Manager in a nursing home and therefore having firsthand knowledge of the patients and their caregivers I would emphatically state that the elderly should be cared for by their family until there is absolutely no other choice. I sincerely hope that I never have to put a family member in a nursing home or become a patient at one myself.

Anyone is going to be happier and fare better in the comfort of familiar surroundings. It is a well known fact that attitude has everything to do with the healing process when a patient is battling a severe illness. Going to a nursing home already places the patient at a disadvantage, arriving under stress in an unfamiliar place. They often feel rejected and abandoned by their family and loved ones and spend hours crying. Some patients never overcome that feeling and their days are spent in lonely tears.

Loss of dignity is a severe blow to anyone's self esteem. The patients are herded like cattle to a common bath area, often rolled in geriatric chairs by their CNA to the showers with nothing more than a sheet draped over them and I have seen them sent down the hall completely naked. No, the nursing home I worked at was not unlike the rest. All of them operate in pretty much the same manner and most are as understaffed in nursing care as the hospitals. As a matter of fact, the nursing home I worked for was considered to be the best in the area and there were several.

Bed sores develop often because of the lack of sufficient staff. One or two CNAs (Certified Nursing Assistant) will be assigned to each hall. These halls hold as many as thirty to forty patients. It goes to reason that the CNA cannot sit with your family member twenty four hours a day.

Not only do bed sores develop, the patients are often subjected to, and catch, terribly communicable diseases like MRSA, a highly contagious, serious, and often deadly form of Staph infection. These patients are isolated and all precautions taken once it is discovered they have MRSA or equally serious communicable diseases but it has left others exposed to it before it was diagnosed. These diseases are often picked up during hospital stays and brought back into the nursing home.

Pneumonia, other respiratory illnesses, and influenza can race through a nursing home where patients have compromised immune systems. I lost my own grandmother like this in 1996. An epidemic of influenza hit the nursing home my grandmother had been admitted to two weeks prior,


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Should elderly patients be cared for by family members or by health care professionals?

Family
  • by Velma aka Shammah

    My first real eye opener to care of the elderly in retirement homes and other such facilities came when I was first starting

    read more

  • 2 of 56

    by Deborah Chaney

    This debate would not be a contemporary issue if we each held our traditions and family in the highest regard. People judge

    read more

Pros
  • 1 of 39

    by Zina Leone

    If it was a different day and age, I would be saying elderly patients should definitely be cared for by family members. I've

    read more

  • 2 of 39

    by Ted Sherman

    Depends (at age 82, I may soon be wearing 'em) on many factors about family relationships, money, health of the elderly parent,

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Should elderly patients be cared for by family members or by health care professionals? ?
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

228713

Featured Partner

Nicki Leach Foundation

My hope is that every person with cancer can smile because someone touched his or her life. So many of you made Nick...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA