Channel Button

There are 34 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #5 by Helium's members.

Education   >

Educational Philosophy

Get a Widget for this title

Are gifted and talented programs elitist?

While the politics of "No Child Left Behind" are questionable, the underlying mandate is admirable. As educators, we should provide for the educational needs of all our students. The focus tends to be on struggling and disadvantaged students, while "gifted and talented" programs are left to languish. In part this stems from a lack of teaching staff and classrooms to accomodate even more specialized classes. The idea that such programs are elitist, giving an unfair advantage to some students, while making the rest feel inferior by comparison, is the other primary stumbling block.

A gifted and talented program is not intended to be elitist. It is designed to help students develop their abilities and advance their knowledge, as with every other student. Students are not all equal in ability - a fact that everyone acknowledges when it comes to struggling students. Some students do have greater talent in certain areas. This may be inherent in their genetics, it may have grown from a child's natural curiousity in a subject, or it may stem from involved parents who have nurtured their child's intellect at home. The last is the one that seems unfair to many people. Parents who have a solid college education are better able to pass on learning to their children independently of school. The college educated parents also tend to have the higher paying jobs, so that money and talented students often appear to be linked.

The truth is, yes, having money and a college education does help when raising a child. It is not, however, a guarantee that a child will be gifted or talented, nor is it a barrier to the children of non-college graduates. Child rearing also imparts values and outlooks - work ethic, competitiveness, self-improvement, helplessness, resentment - students will tend to emulate whichever traits their parents model for them. Those factors combine with the child's natural inclinations and abilities to determine what their educational needs and goals are.

For the child who has innate gifts in one or more subject areas, and has been encouraged to develop them, a gifted and talented program is truly a necessity. A student who has already learned on their own much of the course content will be bored at best in the regular classroom, or worse, come to resent school and stifle their future learning potential. A gifted and talented program will offer more work, more challenges and more learning to those students who are motivated enough to want it. They do not benefit


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Are gifted and talented programs elitist?

  • 1 of 34

    by Trenna Sue Hiler

    As an educator I would eliminate the term of "gifted and talented" and replace it will the generic term of " special needs".

    read more

  • 2 of 34

    by Mark Butler

    Asking if Gifted and Talented programs are elitist is on a par with asking if high school and college sports are elitist.

    read more

  • 3 of 34

    by R. Renee Bembry

    In determining whether or not Gifted and Talented Education (GATE) programs are elitist, one must consider the facts that:

    read more

  • 4 of 34

    by Greg Slack

    ARE GIFTED AND TALENTED PROGRAMS ELITIST
    As a father of three children two of whom are in TAG or advanced classes, I may have

    read more

  • 5 of 34

    by Ernest Capraro

    While the politics of "No Child Left Behind" are questionable, the underlying mandate is admirable. As educators, we should

    read more

View All Articles on:
Are gifted and talented programs elitist?

Add your voice

Know something about Are gifted and talented programs elitist??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

Helium Debate

Cast your vote!

Is competition in school helpful or harmful to the students?

Click for your side.

98330

Featured Partner

Americans for Prosperity

Americans for Prosperity (AFP) is committed to educating citizens about economic policy and mobilizing those citizens...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA