Channel Button

There are 30 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #6 by Helium's members.

Arts & Humanities   >

Political Philosophy

Get a Widget for this title

The problems with Communism

Political ideologies exists to fix imperfections in our own nature. Communism sought to equalize all through distribution of wealth and promotion of a common over individual good. What happened? We did. See some comrades appeared to be more equal than others. Was Marx even close? Sure in a vacuum where we all think and feel alike? His mom said it best, "Karl should spend more time earning capital than writing about it." Her own greed doomed the system.

Politically it failed because you can't rule people who are starving while a select few enjoy comfort and wealth. Marx called for the workers to rise up against managers. Sounds great but what happens next? Well, gotta make stuff and some must work while others manage. Oops got rise up again to rid ourselves of the new batch of managers. So, perpetual revolution was the only way to keep the system growing. Problem is revolutions are a pain in the butt. Also they tend to be bloody and messy which has a nasty habit of endangering those who called for it in the first place.

Economically, greed and envy doomed Communism. "I don't want a blue shirt, I want a red shirt", simple and clear problem with a system designed to meet everyone's needs. "Why should I bust my hump making 20 tanks a month when I get paid the same for making only 10?" No motive to do more unless you face a Stalinist purge. And facing death tends to make one unhappy which requires either more gun totters to enforce the threat or get ousted in favor of a lower death threat government.

As a philosophy Communism is a dandy. Hippies embraced the ideals of equality and everything being free which Marx purported as a natural outcome of his system. Well, those same Hippies are bitching about Social Security and would love to get a new iPhone. Sorry, no such thing as a free lunch. Because even if it was free our own experiences and greed would make us wary of it. "Why is this free? What is wrong with it?"

Communism's attack on religion was likewise a fatal flaw. People need something to believe in that is beyond them. A Politburo is not far enough beyond them or mystical enough to ensure faith. Faith is hope in the dark when everything says your not going to get out of this unhurt. Faith binds us together and without it then why bother? Marx was angry at the abuses of organized religion just like another German forbear. Luther sought reform and ended up leading a Protestant revolution. Marx, I think hoped to do much the same. He must have slept through what


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

The problems with Communism

  • 1 of 30

    by John Devera

    The problem with Communism is that it does not exist outside the very small and vervently homogenous examples of small communities.

    read more

  • 2 of 30

    by Matt Davis

    The Problem with Communism

    Communism, called "Revolutionary Proletarian Socialism" or "Marxism," was created by Karl Marx

    read more

  • 3 of 30

    by Mark Hopkins

    Karl Marx's analysis of History led him to conclude that all societies would evolve through various stages, from monarchy

    read more

  • 4 of 30

    by Gary C. Gibson

    Human nature is corrupt and all closed geographic societies become authoritarian eventually. Government bureaucracies become

    read more

  • 5 of 30

    by Jerry Curtis

    The problems with Communism are directly related to its historical failure as a system of government and social control.

    read more

View All Articles on:
The problems with Communism

Add your voice

Know something about The problems with Communism?
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

Helium Debate

Cast your vote!

Big Bang or Big Man: How in the heck did we get here?

Click for your side.

235799

Featured Partner

eSpindle Learning

eSpindle Learning builds literacy one word at a time. Our mission is to help learners of all skill levels develop ...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA