Home > Politics, News & Issues > US Politics > US Immigration
Created on: July 01, 2007
The fate offered to illegals under Bushite "Comprehensive Immigration Reform" is the same as the fate offered to Africans during and shortly after the trans-atlantic slave trade. That, to be sure, is a fairly bleak fate, which promises a legacy of hardship and civil wrongs for which a new generation of Americans will one day have to account.
"Amnesty" in the latest immigration bill isn't true amnesty by any stretch of imagination; Amnesty is what happens when a government gaurantees that a political person or group of people will never be punished for a particular crime they are known to have comitted. Illegal immigrants will not have that gaurantee; under Bush's Comprehensive Immigration bill, twelve million illgal immigrants will be offered a so-called "Z Visa" which will grant them permanent residence within the United States, but will NOT grant them citizenship in the United States. The Z Visa is conditional: so long as immigrants remain gainfully employed and avoid criminal activity, they can stay as much as they want. And of course, this gives them a new path to citizenship... at least so far as it puts them on the bottom of an eight-year-long waiting list for green cards and, ultimately, naturalization.
At least under the Bush plan, the fate of illegal aliens is to become a new race of second-class quasi-citizens, deprived of any form of constitutional rights, political power, or even the right to vote. Not since the civil rights movement of the 60s has such a thing existed in this nation; then, as now, massive corporations depend on cheap labor of a powerless, controllable, voiceless mass of people who can be easily intimidated or abused into submission. The civil upheaval of the 1960s made sure that no black man would ever be forced to pick cotton (or anything else) for pennies a day again; already, corporate America has finally found their replacement.
What should be the fate of illegal immigrants in the United States? That's just a matter of common sense: they should be dealt with according to the laws that already exist in this country. They should be given a chance to become American citizens, to contribute positively to American society, to learn the culture, language, history and heritage of their addopted nation and join the brotherhood of our proud society. If they cannot do this, they should be asked to leave; again, this is a matter of common sense. It goes without saying, of course, but common sense isn't as common as it should be: the fate of illegal immigrants should be different from the fate planned for them by the Bush Regime. Indeed, for the sake of our future and our national conscience, it MUST be. We have been here before, and it's time to stop repeating our mistakes.
Learn more about this author, Kyle Allen.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:
What should be the fate of illegal aliens found in the United States?
In order to determine the appropriate fate of illegal aliens, I must first define the seriousness of the problem.
In the
The term "illegal alien" could be softened to something that does not label individuals who are in a country illegally as
The debate over illegal aliens and what to do about them is heating up on the cusp of the House of Representatives approval
What should be the fate of illegal aliens? That’s a hard and scary question. The question implies that they are due
Will we all be speaking Spanish in the near future?
This kid-glove approach to the illegal immigration dilemma is totally
View All Articles on: What should be the fate of illegal aliens found in the United States?
Helium Debate
Cast your vote!
Is the "abstinence only" educational initiative to reduce teen pregnancies just?
Click for your side.
Featured Partner
Why Tuesday has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause. Browse Why Tuesday's featured titles, pick an issue and write! You can also learn new perspectives on issues that you care about.more