Where Knowledge Rules

Home:

Pets & Animals

Debate_icon Get a Widget for this title

Have 'Animal Rights' gone too far?

Results so far:

No
58% 918 votes Total: 1589 votes
Yes
42% 671 votes

When do convictions based on the concepts of humanity and compassion result in acts of poisoning, arson, assault, and robbery? It is hard to imagine the answer, yet these very acts are among the tactics used by some animal rights activists who claim they are acting out of sympathy and concern. While they argue that they are seeking humane treatment for animals, they hinder scientists' constant search for cures and answers to diseases that plague humans humans who have emotions, relationships, responsibilities, and futures. Since research involving animals actually helps preserve human lives, it must be done.

In looking at this controversial issue, one cannot deny that animal research has led to major medical breakthroughs. Some of the most valuable discoveries have led to the development of antibiotics, anti-cancer , and treatments for kidney disease (Haugen 17). Animals have greatly assisted scientists in developing antibiotics to treat dangerous bacterial diseases. Bacterial infections such as pneumonia, typhoid, cholera, and scarlet fever can now all be treated with antibiotics that were developed with and tested on animals before being used to treat people (Haugen 17). Cancer, one of the world's greatest health concerns, is a primary focus area of medical research. According to Nancy Day, "If animal research on cancer had been restricted twenty years ago, more than half of the anticancer in use today would not be available" (82). One can only imagine the difference this startling statistic would make in the lives of today's cancer victims. Another area where key medical breakthroughs have been made is that of kidney disease, a devastating illness. In its most extreme forms, it damages the kidneys to the point that they can no longer function on their own; the only two treatment choices are dialysis treatments or a kidney transplant. The procedure of dialysis on a kidney machine was developed as a direct result of work on dogs and rabbits. The primary used to treat those on dialysis is called heparin and it too was discovered by experiments on dogs. Finally, the very procedure of a kidney transplant was developed through animal testing and it is in wide use today (Haugen 21). Clearly, animal experimentation has been a vital element in aiding scientists in developing treatments for all of these dangerous conditions.

In addition to providing medical breakthroughs for the good of humans, research on animals directly benefits both pets and farm animals. According


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Have 'Animal Rights' gone too far?

Yes
  • 1 of 50

    by Web Rydr

    One of our "divine rights" is "dominion over the animals." Given to us by God as one of our duties. We are responsible for

    read more

  • 2 of 50

    by Mary Knetter

    Growing up on a dairy farm I have been exposed to many animals. Our farm had dogs, cats, cows, a horse and countless wild

    read more

No
  • 1 of 73

    by Robin Loving

    In every Movement that involves individuals, or groups of people who are extremely passionate about a cause, there will

    read more

  • 2 of 73

    by M. L. Kiser

    No, Animal Rights have not gone nearly far enough. For anyone who thinks that they have, remember that we human beings are

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Have 'Animal Rights' gone too far??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

121751

Featured Partner

Sunshine Week

Sunshine Week is a nonpartisan, good-government effort led by the American Society of Newspaper Editors, but with a c...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA