Where Knowledge Rules

Religion & Spirituality:

Spirituality

Get a Widget for this title

Mind and body connection: Do we have a soul

I had a cat die tonight, about an hour ago. We noticed it was sick and listless today, but after the vet had closed, unfortunately. We thought we would take it to the vet the first thing in the morning.
That didn't work out. We kept him by the bed on an old pillow tonight. He's normally an outside cat but it's cold out in addition to the cat being sick. After hardly being able to move he suddenly started crashing around, trying to get out of his bed. His mouth was opening and closing and he made a moaning noise.


I took it to the kitchen to give him some water. I didn't really know what to do for him or if he wanted water, but my wife suggested it and I had no other plan of action. He wouldn't drink the water, I sort of stuck his mouth in the bowl, just enough to let him know it was there.
That didn't work so I just laid him down and petted him. A brown liquid came out of his mouth. I held him with his head down so that the puke would run out and not choke him.
In retrospect I think that's when he died. But at the time I didn't think so.
There was no real sign of death. There was no "giving up the ghost" as old folks say. His mouth still opened and closed, the jaw muscles working, but he got colder and stiffer. There were even twitching muscles around his mouth long after he was stiff.
It just strikes me that there was no sign at all. You expect something, you know? A soul rising into the air would be good. That's the sort of thing the religious and the spiritual expect. Being one of them I always want to believe there is a soul, or something.
Even the non-religious scientific establishment seems to think there is a sign. No pulse, a cessation of breathing, a beeping monitor, a wave pattern on a monitor becoming a flat line. But there was none of that. Every death I've ever seen I could never be sure they were dead. It was harder with a cat, I couldn't take a pulse because I don't know cat physiology. His breathing had been faint before so I couldn't check that. Long after I was 90% sure he was dead I held him up to my ear and was sure I heard a heartbeat. He was stiff, but still twitched and something was making noise. But then I heard gurgling of intestines....it was probably just something settling around inside him.
Since I wasn't sure he was dead, not 100 percent, and it's dark out, I laid him on the pillow he died on, placed him in the bathtub and there he sits. Very stiff now. But I just couldn't bring myself to dispose of him until I was absolutely sure he was dead.
And there is just no way of knowing that. What separates the living from the dead, really? Movement? A soul? A set of biological patterns that mean nothing but we file under the name of "life"?
There has to be something that separates the quick and the dead, doesn't there?

Learn more about this author, Maxwell Hammer.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Mind and body connection: Do we have a soul

  • 1 of 34

    by Steve Marshall

    Do we have a self, or a soul or do we really ever exist separately at all? Are we just another piece of nature and life

    read more

  • 2 of 34

    by Renae Richardson

    A man is the sum of three parts body, mind, and the soul (spirit). It is impossible for one to live if any of these parts

    read more

  • 3 of 34

    by David Neil Bain

    Do we have a soul?

    Do we have a soul? No. Or yes, if you hold that the body and soul are one and when the body dies, so does

    read more

  • 4 of 34

    by Roman Del Bosque

    Even if the Greeks were the first to describe such concepts as the mind, body and soul this does not mean their conclusions

    read more

  • 5 of 34

    by Maggie Larkin

    Is the mind merely a comforting mirage to the Physical being? Or are they two separate bodies working together to create

    read more

View All Articles on:
Mind and body connection: Do we have a soul

Add your voice

Know something about Mind and body connection: Do we have a soul?
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

Helium Debate

Cast your vote!

Is mind-reading real or fake?

Click for your side.

128686

Featured Partner

Text and Academic Authors Association

The Text and Academic Authors Association (TAA) is the only authoring association devoted exclusively to serving text...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA