4 of 64

Write now Article Tools

As working vet, I see both sides of the coin. This is a very touchy subject! And with good reason- In the place where I live, Pit bulls have been banned... The funny thing is this- there is NO way that I as a vet can actually prove that a dog in question is a pit bull (or any other breed) or not.

Genetically, there is effectively no difference- so there is no way that it can be proven that a particular dog is a particular breed! Even if it is pretty obvious- (though funnily enough, there seems to be a lot of red nosed Staffordshire terriers around here these days...)

I have met some dangerous dogs in my working life as a vet- the most dangerous was a Japanese Akita- I took one look, and just knew. "It would be suicide to step out from behind my table..." So I examined at a distance, without eye contact. Scary dog! Then again, the most aggressive dog I have ever treated was a Chihuahua!

I also had a friend (another vet) who had a client with a small fluffy dog- and you know what?- If the dog got onto the bed before her at night, she slept on the floor!

My point is this- ANY breed of dog is potentially dangerous...

Nearly all of this has to do with how the dog is treated and trained, especially from about 8-12 weeks of age (this is when the dog is most impressionable). Many people who buy 'aggressive', or 'dangerous' breeds, buy them because they want that sort of dog- and then they make them so by how they treat and train them. Some of these breeds do have more aggressive tendencies than others, but I believe it is how they are treated that leads to how they behave.

Dogs have personalities, just like people- some are harder, or more aggressive, even within a breed.

So- No- we should not be banning certain dog breeds! We should be banning certain people from owning any sort of dog, more like it!- however, this opens a whole other can of worms.

I believe that 99% of puppies can make a good dog, and I also believe that some dog breeds are not for 'beginner' owners. Be responsible- take your puppy to puppy school, and obedience, keep them properly confined, never leave them alone with kids
(what would your dog do if a little one poked him in the eye, hard?)

Enjoy your dogs,they are such wonderful friends!

Learn more about this author, Dr Edward BVSc.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Add your voice

Know something about Should we be banning certain dog breeds??
We want to hear your view. Write now!