Home > Education > Secondary School > High School Humanities
Results so far:
| Yes | 51% | 310 votes | Total: 609 votes | |
| No | 49% | 299 votes |
Created on: December 16, 2009 Last Updated: December 20, 2009
Being a student myself and having learned about the Holocaust, I can tell you that from my own experiences that the Holocaust is emphasized much more than Hitler. Hitler, we were taught, was brilliant. A charismatic genius who could rise up to lead the war torn nation of Germany to supremacy. He was brilliant; when the German flocks listened to him speak, they stood and cheered, no matter what he said. Looking back at Germany after World War 1, we were told to imagine how those Germans felt, alone, embarrassed, angry. So Hitler in his sadistic brilliance composed a plan to catapult him to power while restoring the moral of the German people. His plant was fiendishly simple, blame everything on a scapegoat. The people of Germany were leaderless, angry, and confused, so when Hitler came preaching his message that no, it was not the Germans' fault that they had lost World War 1 but rather the fault of the Jews, homosexuals, Roma, and other ethnic minorities, the German people, hungry for retribution, bit onto his bait and thus started one of the darkest periods ih history. From there, the people of Germany began to terrorize those minorities first by shutting them up in ghettos and then by shipping them off to concentration and death camps. Hitler was not the full tree of genocide, but he had planted the seed.
From there, we focused on the Holocaust itself. We experienced this event by reading Night by Elie Wiesel, a holocaust survivor. In no place in his book does Elie smear Hitler and this rubbed off on us. We realized that while Hitler instigated the discrimination, it was the German people, hungry for revenge, who had blown the whole issue out of proportion. Hitler himself did not order death marches or crimes against Jews. We went on to read the whole book through and through and see how horrendous this event was. Sometimes we did laugh at the irony or images portrayed in the book, but behind our quiet chuckles, each one of us could feel the heavy burden and sadness that this past history instilled on us.
What perhaps really cemented these experiences was our visit to the Holocaust Museum (notice that it is not the Hitler Museum). There we stood in the cattle cars where hundreds of Jews were packed in to be transported to camps and for the first time felt the fear, anger, confusion, that the Holocaust victims
Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:
Is Hitler over-emphasized and the Holocaust under-emphasized in schools?
No
Yes
View all articles on: Is Hitler over-emphasized and the Holocaust under-emphasized in schools?
Featured Partner
Why Tuesday has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause. Browse Why Tuesday's featured titles, pick an issue and write! You can also learn new perspectives on issues that you care about.more