Where Knowledge Rules

Home:

Parenting & Pregnancy

Debate_icon Get a Widget for this title

Should children under 10 attend funerals?

Results so far:

Yes
74% 427 votes Total: 579 votes
No
26% 152 votes


SHOULD CHILDREN UNDER 10 ATTEND FUNERALS?


My friends Marshall and Gloria had one son, after years of trying. Gloria, a genuine workaholic, left most of Little Marsh's playtime up to Marshall, who did all the things dads do with kids - at least, as many as he could manage. Marshall had been ill for years with one of those chronic diseases that wasn't actually supposed to take him out before he reached 40, but one muggy night it did.

Gloria called 911, but Marshall had gone to a place no one could shock him back from. Awakened by the hubbub, Marsh wandered into the bedroom just as the morgue staff was loading his father onto a gurney. "Go back to bed!" Gloria almost shrieked at the toddler. "Daddy's sleeping!"

Everyone but Gloria thought the child should go to Marshall's funeral; she wouldn't hear of it. Marsh stayed with my family until after the ceremonies, when the relatives returned to the house. Then he looked from face to face, wondering why his mother looked so sad, why his grandmother wouldn't stop crying, why people stroked his head and pinched his cheeks. And where was his dad? He walked from room to room, calling to him, but he didn't jump out of the closet and he didn't peek out from under the bed. His briefcase was still there by the front door, so he hadn't gone to work. His mother's response to his enquiry was to clasp him to her chest and burst into tears. He didn't ask again.

Marsh changed, from a bouncy little boy to a wide-eyed and anxious child who wouldn't let his mother out of his sight when she was at home and fretted for her when she was not. As an adult, he reflected on his belief that it would have been better for him to attend final rites for his father than to wonder, as he did for years, where his dad had gone and why nobody mentioned him anymore. He and his mother are not close.

There is something humans fear about death. Perhaps it is the not knowing, the fear of Divine retribution for past misdeeds, the permanence of the separation from loved ones. Particularly in a sudden and unanticipated death, the living may have difficulty processing what has happened, and to explain to a small child may seem just too much in the moment. Yet, children want to know. Kept in the dark, they create their own myths about what has befallen the missing person, and conjure up bugaboos far more fierce than the actual situation. Marsh slept fitfully for years. His dad had been sleeping, and people had come and dragged him out of bed and zipped him


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Should children under 10 attend funerals?

Yes
  • 1 of 33

    by Jean C. Fisher

    I can tell you the answer to this question. I can tell you the answer because, when I was a child of two, my father died

    read more

  • 2 of 33

    by Christine Sandor

    The loss of a loved one, no matter what your age is traumatic. Even an infant senses the loss as they are keyed into the

    read more

No
  • 1 of 12

    by Vonda Sines

    When it comes to what's best for a child, there are exceptions to many rules. However, I consider it unwise and sometimes

    read more

  • 2 of 12

    by Joanne Smith

    Out of the respect of those who have taken their children to funerals I will not say that I feel that it is wrong. I do

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Should children under 10 attend funerals??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

193696

Featured Partner

International Human Rights Group

IHRG Mission Statement: Standing for Religious Liberties for All We believe that religious liberties are the fo...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA