Home > Arts & Humanities > Visual Arts > Making Art
Created on: August 26, 2009
There are various categories of great art. There is personal great art of the artist. There is contemporary greatness. And there is perpetual greatness. It is the same in all types of art. Sometimes an artist is fortunate enough to have a work be great in his own eyes or ears, in the eyes or ears of those around him, and in the eyes or ears of future art lovers.
Take for instance Tchaikovsky's "1812 Overture." He thought it was mainly a bunch of noise. He did it because he was commissioned to compose it in honor of the Russian victory over Napoleon. The people must have enjoyed it because it has been considered a great piece of music for nearly a century and a half.
Then there is Beethoven. People praised his "Seventh Symphony" which is one of my favorite of his too. But they didn't appreciate his "Eighth Symphony" which was not as monumental. But he loved it and thought it should be rated higher. It's good. But I don't consider it as great as his third, fifth, sixth, seventh, or ninth.
Leonardo DaVinci loved his painting "The Mona Lisa" and took it with him where he went in France and Italy sort of like an artist portfolio. The public loved it too and it is what people think of first when they think of DaVinci. He was the fortunate artist that created a work he thought was great and so did the public.
A piece of art that is considered perpetually great should appeal to the appropriate senses and have qualities that will allow it to remain great. Take for instance Bach and Telemann. Three centuries ago, Telemann was considered possibly the greatest composer in Germany. He was in such demand that he composed cantatas for two churches every week. In Leipzig, the church Bach eventually serviced wanted Telemann. But he was too busy and wanted too much money. So they had to settle for Bach. Shortly after Bach's death, his music lost favor in public and he was nearly forgotten. But around a century later, Mendelssohn re-discovered Bach and conducted a performance of his "Saint Matthew's Passion" which I love to hear when I'm driving on my first day of vacation. I like the music of Telemann. But most of it is forgotten while most of Bach's music is considered the greatest music ever composed. He loved his music and dedicated it to God. That could be why so much of it sounds so divine.
Van Gogh loved his painting Sunflowers which I believe was the only work he sold during his lifetime. He sold it for money to buy supplies. He
Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:
What makes something great art
Great art is the product of any combination of factors. There is no one thing, or one attribute that will determine if a
Good art connects the dots for you. It links the intellect to an emotion and makes you feel good - or at least smart. It
by Gary Maclean
Now that's good art, I remember saying to myself, under my breath, as I viewed one particular photo from the dozens of prints,
by Rick Badman
There are various categories of great art. There is personal great art of the artist. There is contemporary greatness.
by John Devera
"What is art." That's the sort of question undergraduates mull over as they smoke pot on a Friday night after their econ
View All Articles on: What makes something great art
Helium Debate
Cast your vote!
Are people who draw anthro (anthropomorphic) characters fetishists or artists?
Click for your side.
Featured Partner
Time 4A Change (T4AC) is committed to educating citizens about social issues and mobilizing those citizens as participants in civil discourse. T4AC is an organization of grassroots leaders who engage citizens in the name of social issues...more