4 of 8

Write now Article Tools

Understanding Charter Schools Through The Eyes of Others

It is interesting to view an issue through the lens of different observers. What one person sees as a sensible argument may make no sense at all to several others. We see it in everyday life, especially in the op-ed columns and among the rants and raves of politicians. Gaining a consensus on any issue is tough to accomplish, unless the group involved is incredibly like-minded.

The different lenses do not change when the topic is education. Just as there are 7-8 designated learning styles (at least, according to Mr. Gardner), there are also dozens of preferred methods to run the education business, both inside and outside of the classroom.

In the first paper, I introduced the two candidates for governor of Virginia in the upcoming 2010 election, Creigh Deeds and Bob McDonnell. Of course, as a Democrat and a Republican running for the same office, they have to disagree on some issues, if only for political purposes. I noted that they have some disagreements on charter schools. But who and what are making them disagree?

Continuing with the topic of charter schools, it is no surprise that the two gubernatorial candidates don't necessarily see eye-to-eye on the subject of opening more. The topic is historically a hot button issue, especially in Virginia. Even the beginning of Virginia charter schools was noted for its controversy. Back in the early 1970's, Arlington County became the first jurisdiction in the Commonwealth to open a charter school. Although the school did not mention the word 'charter,' the opening of H-B Woodlawn Alternative School was met with resistance from school choice critics. Because of its individualized, caring environment, coupled with the love and peace theme of the youth at that time, the Woodlawn project was quickly labeled Hippie High. In spite of the name-calling, the school was successful with its impressive number of participants for the AP exams. Woodlawn continues to flourish today, as an offshoot of Yorktown High School.

Virginia's problem is not unusual. In theory, many groups and individuals are proponents of individualism and free choice. The problem only arises when free choice takes money or power away from another individual or group.

It is hard to find an interest group that exists solely for the abolition of charter schools. However, there are many interest groups that support the development of charter schools and

• 1
• 2
• next page >>

Add your voice

Know something about Understanding the charter school movement in America?
We want to hear your view. Write now!