Home > Politics, News & Issues > Politics, News & Issues (Other)
Created on: June 30, 2009 Last Updated: July 02, 2009
Governments move in one of two directions, they are either moving in the direction of freedom or they are moving in the direction of tyranny. People are either becoming more free or they are becoming less free. When a government writes and makes laws that do not protect its citizens from foreign and domestic enemies, but laws that are to protect its citizens from themselves, they are moving toward tyranny.
When the U.S. government makes laws that restrict its people from smoking in public places, speaking how they want, in the format they want (I am referring to the constant threat of new 'Hate Crimes' laws and 'Fairness Doctrine' laws that may prevent talk radio from continuing), using the kind of light bulbs that they want, driving the kind of car that they want, watching television in a non-high-definition format if they want, using gasoline for their car that does not contain any ethanol if they want, using their air conditioner without the fear of paying a much higher bill because of the passage of a new 'Cap and Trade' law if they want; there is reason to think that the U.S. is moving away from freedom and moving towards tyranny.
To say that tyranny should only be reserved from those governments that physically oppress their people that brutally beat and kill their citizens, is a failure to understand how some governments become governments of tyranny. Sigmund Freud believed that Germany proved they were more advanced because instead of burning Jews they were burning their books (referring to the fact that they were burning his and other books written by Jewish authors). However, perhaps to Freud's surprise, they were not proving to be a more advanced society, for instead they were advancing further in to tyranny - as first it was their books and next it was their authors that they were destroying.
A nation who claims to love freedom in any form or fashion must embrace it for everyone, or it will soon find that it exists for no one. The United States government believes that it is passing laws to help its citizens, by manipulating them to change their behaviors. An accusation that can be made against many of its leaders both Right and Left, Conservative and Liberal, Republican and Liberal.
However, like so many times before leaders with good intentions make laws that only do more harm than good to others, and are passed quickly and assuredly without any thought of what it will mean down the road. Laws against the sale and purchase of alcohol proved
Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:
Should governments try to manipulate the personal behavior of citizens?
by Phineas
The entire legal system is an attempt to manipulate the behavior of the governed people. Laws, through several routes, are
There are many ways governments manipulate their populace. The simple enactment of any policy or law will serve to manipulate
by Bob Schmidt
It would seem obvious that governments should try to manipulate undesired behavior of those being governed.
Should governments try to manipulate the personal behavior of citizens? Please, oh please, tell me this is a trick question.
by Gene Denardo
All governments control the personal behaviour of its citizens. Government is defined as "a monopoly of force within a region",
View All Articles on: Should governments try to manipulate the personal behavior of citizens?
Helium Debate
Cast your vote!
Is earning money the only way to become successful?
Click for your side.
Featured Partner
Foundation for Research on Economics and the Environment (FREE)
FREE advances conservation and environmental values by applying modern science and America's founding ideals to policy debates. FREE is comprised of intellectual entrepreneurs explaining how economic incentives, secure property rights, t...more