Three Problems Employers Face When Asking About Past Convictions

Unfortunately, the language employers use on their applications to inquire about an applicant's criminal history often falls into one of three categories: it is either too narrow, too vague, or too ambiguous. This article will discuss each of these three cases and how they can be damaging to one's business:

Too Narrow

An example of a question that is too narrow is to only ask about felonies. Many standard employment applications only ask if an applicant was convicted of a felony. That allows the application form to be used in all states. However, misdemeanors can be very serious. Under California law, for example, most employers would want to know if an applicant had a conviction for offenses such as fighting with a police officer, illegal possession of weapons, spousal abuse or child abuse, commercial burglary, assault and many other offenses. Yet in California and other states, these can all be misdemeanors. Many serious offenses are plea-bargained down to misdemeanor offenses as well. Without the proper language, an applicant can honestly answer that he or she has not been convicted of a felony even though there may be serious misdemeanor convictions an employer needs to know about. A best practice would be to utilize an application form that asks about past criminal conduct in the broadest language allowed by law in your state

Too Broad

On the other hand, some employers ask questions that are so broad that it improperly covers matters that are protected. An example may be, Have you ever committed a crime? Or Have You Ever Been Convicted of Any Crime? There are a number of limitations under state and federal law concerning what an employer may legally ask about or discover concerning an applicant's or employee's criminal record. In fact, it can be a misdemeanor in California for an employer to knowingly violate some of these rules. Furthermore, if an applicant is placed in a position where he is forced to reveal information about himself that he is legally entitled not to disclose, an employer can actually be sued in some states for defamation by compelled self-publication. In other words, if forced to say something defamatory about himself, an applicant may be able to file a lawsuit against the employer for defamation.

Too Ambiguous

The third mistake is to ask an applicant, Have you ever been convicted of a felony or serious misdemeanor? or Have you ever

• 1
• 2
• next page >>

---

Add your voice

Know something about Legality of employers running background checks on job candidates?
We want to hear your view. Write now!