Home > Entertainment > Movies > Movie Remakes & Adaptations
Created on: February 01, 2007 Last Updated: May 09, 2007
Is Hollywood out of ideas? If one were to look at the number of remakes and sequels out there then a very strong argument could be made in favor of this. Of course there are gems out there that are completely original but often you find these in low-budget or independent films.
One argument has even been made that remakes' are necessary to capitalize on the newest wave of movie goers. When Alfred Hitchcock's timeless classic "Psycho" was remade it was argued that teenagers simply would not watch the original because it was in black and white and that by remaking it in color it would draw a new fan base.
There are many remakes out there that have been successful. Disney is one studio house that has made countless remakes of their classics over the years. "Freaky Friday", and "The Parent Trap" are but two that have been very successful both in their original run and their remakes. Though the originals still stand as classics the issues within are a bit out of date and harder for the older teenager to relate to. Remaking' these films with problems teenagers face in today's world helps them relate better and still provides the basic family value message the originals held.
It goes without saying that the technology today for filmmaking and special effects is far more superior than in previous days. Many classic science fiction movies look almost campy' in light of these facts. But where do you draw the line? Should a movie simply be remade because of these factors?
As a horror fan I have witnessed many remakes over the past few years that are simply unnecessary. Though the scenery shots in "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre" were eerily beautiful, was the new film really necessary when the original still had impact and drove sales with today's generation? Other favorites of mine that have been unnecessarily hit would include "The Fog", "The Hitcher", "The Omen", and "The Haunting" to name but a few. And sadder still is the fact that "Halloween" is in the process of being remade as this article is being written.
The argument will continue to exist on this subject for many years. In this writer's opinion, if a movie still makes you cry, hide under the covers and / or double lock your doors then it has done it's job whether it is in the first, second or third generation of film.
Learn more about this author, Jennifer Brinkle.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:
Arguments for and against movie remakes
by Dan Hiland
John Huston once said, "Don't remake good movies. Remake bad ones!"
Words to live by.
And while I agree with the legendary
by John Gugie
I write this rant just coming off of seeing The Omen (2006).
A summary of my issues with remakes is as follows: pointless
I'll make no secret of the fact that I tend to prefer remakes over the original. The film snob in me wants to deny it, but
by Ashley Smith
The argument for against movie remakes depends on the quality and availability of the original and the intentions of the
by Nicole Ford
When you go to the movies these days, there is a strong chance that the movie you watch is not an original one. Over the
View All Articles on: Arguments for and against movie remakes
Helium Debate
Cast your vote!
Does Heath Ledger's performance in The Dark Knight merit an Oscar?
Click for your side.
Featured Partner
The Goldwater Institute was founded in 1988 by a small group of entrepreneurial Arizonans with the blessing of Senator Barry Goldwater. In keeping with the principles advanced by Senator Goldwater, the Goldwater Institute is dedicated to...more