Channel Button

There are 7 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #1 by Helium's members.

Debate_icon

Pets & Animals   >

Dog Training

Get a Widget for this title

Positive reinforcement or correction based training: Which is the better method?

Results so far:

Reinforce
70% 95 votes Total: 135 votes
Correct
30% 40 votes

Correct or Reinforce? I don't see how anyone could "train" a dog, or any other animal for that matter, without BOTH!


I have raised (or "trained" older dogs) many times, and there is no abuse needed to correct a dog. I also use much, much praise, pats, hugs, smiles, and happy sounds when the animal does good. They want to please you and be with you more than anything else!


Abuse is abuse, plain and simple. If abuse is involved, that human needs corrected, shown the difference between good & not good dog/pet ownership. If abuse happens again, the animal needs removed from that person. Permanently, in a legal manner. Once shown, many pet owners will gladly take advice.


A correction for doing something wrong can be as gentle as taking away an item, shaking your head no, SAYING "no", and then showing it what it can have or can do. Or just gently moving the animal away from something and saying "no", and shaking your head no at it. I'm a firm believer in using body motions with your head or hands as you also say something to it. I also firmly believe in talking to your pets a s much as possible, in simple terms they even possibly can someday learn from you repeating them, as even the TONE of voice tells them things. And the like being talked to! They like being sung to also!


I also have had to use one sheet of a newspaper rolled LOOSELY or folded a couple times, on the rear-end, NOT HURTING THEM but scaring them with the sound of it only, with my voice telling them a simple word or 2 such as "No, go OUT", or "No, no up!", or some such. Hitting or yelling is totally useless & self-defeating, as any animal (or child) only learns to be afraid of you if such methods are used. But if an animal is not corrected gently, firmly, I can only imagine one would have a pretty unpleasant animal for awhile, probably a long while.


With gentle correction and all the love and praise and rewards I can give them, I have had some truly outstanding pets. I have had two dogs who could even say "Out", and that certainly wasn't something they'd ever have done had I been abusive and taught them to fear me. A Golden Retriever/Sheltie I had learned 89 little "tricks" or activities I showed her how to do. Yes, she was a way smart dog! She was my furry child. There's very little we wouldn't have done for her or she for us. We sometimes took that to extremes, but we enjoyed every minute of it, and so did she. She loved to learn new things. (When she was ill once, she showed me it


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Positive reinforcement or correction based training: Which is the better method?

Correct
  • 1 of 2

    by Judy J. Lehrman

    Correct or Reinforce? I don't see how anyone could "train" a dog, or any other animal for that matter, without BOTH!


    I have

    read more

  • 2 of 2

    by Christine Bennett

    My side of the debate took some thinking about because actually this side the correct' side could also be on the reinforce

    read more

Reinforce
  • 1 of 5

    by Am.

    With training, it is important to understand that four types of consequences can happen: positive punishment (add bad thing),

    read more

  • 2 of 5

    by Barbaraanne Helberg

    Why Positive Reinforcement Works Best in Dog Training

    Dogs are much like small children in their emotional responses. A

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Positive reinforcement or correction based training: Which is the better method??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

100501

Featured Partner

Presidential Climate Action Project (PCAP)

The Presidential Climate Action Project (PCAP) has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause....more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA