by Raven Lebeau

Created on: April 16, 2009   Last Updated: January 30, 2010

Cats and dogs can both make wonderful pets. For many homeowners, the best solution to the cat-or-dog dilemma is getting both. However, if you are undecided about which pet is best for you, there are some factors to consider.

1. Time commitment.

Dogs, as a general rule, do not use the litter box, which means they will need to be let outside several times a day. Ideally, a dog should be walked at least once a day, if not twice. High energy dogs thrive on a lifestyle that includes plenty of exercise such as playing fetch or tug or war. A high energy dog forced to lead a sedentary lifestyle may exhibit behavior problems as well as develop health complications.

Cats, in contrast, can be left alone for many hours as long as they have access to clean water and a litter box. As a rule, cats do not enjoy being walked on leashes. While cats love it when you play with them by dangling a string or shining a laser pointer, they will also happily play by themselves or with each other.

If you have a work schedule that involves long hours when no one is in your home, or if you simply do not want to pay a lot of attention to your pet every day, then a cat is probably a better choice than a dog for you.

2. Noise tolerance.

Almost all dogs bark. If you live in an apartment and have sensitive neighbors, getting a dog is probably not the right choice for you. Cats are much quieter pets, although vocalizations will vary by breed and individual. Siamese cats, for example, will be very prone to mewing. However, even the most vocal of cats will be less disruptive than a dog.

3. Desire to train your pet.

If you like the idea of having an animal companion that does "tricks", then a cat is probably not the best choice for you. Dogs are much more responsive to reinforcements and will readily learn commands such as "sit" and "shake hands".

4. Social aspects of pet ownership.

For some people, having a dog is a great way to socialize. You can meet people by taking your dog to an obedience class, walking him at the dog park, or just taking him around the neighborhood. Dogs who are especially well-behaved can be trained as "therapy dogs" and taken to visit patients in hospitals and nursing homes. If you like the idea of using your pet to interact with other people, then a dog is the right choice for you.

Cats, in contrast, prefer to stay home. Unless your cat is very well-socialized, he may even be afraid of visitors who come to your home.

Learn more about this author, Raven Lebeau.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.