Channel Button

There are 13 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #5 by Helium's members.

Debate_icon

Pets & Animals   >

Dog Training

Get a Widget for this title

Victoria Stilwell or Cesar Millan: Who would you call?

Results so far:

Stilwell
38% 171 votes Total: 456 votes
Millan
62% 285 votes

Science is More Important than Metaphysical Mumbo-Jumbo in Dog Training

I have been training dogs since I was nine years old, and I remember hearing all sorts of methods that were offered for dog training when I was a child. One that I particularly remember is the method of training first pioneered by William Koehler. This training method was something akin to the old way of breaking horses or maybe the old Prussian way of training soldiers. Harsh punishment, strict control, and very little freedom were de rigueur. I distinctly remember one method that Koehler suggested that people use to break their dogs of hole-digging. First, you take the garden hose and fill the hole with water. Then you take your errant dog and do some "enhanced interrogation techniques" on him. After you nearly drown the dog, he won't want to dig holes again.

Of course, such methods are nonsense and border abject cruelty. These methods have been rejected by the discipline of animal behavior, and certified animal behaviorists now use much more gentle methods to correct poor behavior in dogs. Dr. Ian Dunbar, Dr. Nicholas Dodman, and Dr. Patricia McConnell all suggest that these methods are better than the Prussian army techniques. They do use some "correction," but all of these corrections are focused on understanding how the dog's brain works. Dogs cannot remember actions for more than a few seconds, so any correction has to be short and quick, as well as closely connected to the undesired behavior. Doing otherwise is simply follow.

These are the types of methods that Victoria Stilwell uses on her show. They are appropriate for the average person to use, because they encourage the proper setting of boundaries and limitations on dogs within a framework that is both user friendly for dogs and owners. If a dog does the wrong, thing it does receive a correction, but if it does the right thing, it receives a reward. The corrections are often isolation, which is used in raising children in the form of "time-outs."

These are the methods that virtually any certified animal behaviorist will suggest that anyone do to develop a well-behaved dog. However, the old Koehler method has suddenly returned in the form of Cesar Millan. Although Millan is not as severe as Koehler was, the methods are essentially nothing more than punishment. Some of these punishments are physical punishments that may work, but they also may be more or less a good way for the owner to get bitten. And Millan gets bitten all the


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Victoria Stilwell or Cesar Millan: Who would you call?

Stilwell
  • 1 of 5

    by Hope Darby

    As a long-time fan of both "It's Me or the Dog," and "Dog Whisperer," deciding between Victoria Stilwell and Cesar Millan

    read more

  • 2 of 5

    by Liane Laskoske

    Having been a dog-owner most of my life, and having trained some of the worst dogs into loving pets, I prefer Stillwell's

    read more

Millan
  • 1 of 8

    by Sandra Goodwin

    Comparing Ms. Stilwell to Mr. Millan is like comparing apples and oranges. Mr. Millan states quite clearly that he is not

    read more

  • 2 of 8

    by Amelia Bines

    Victoria Stilwell and Cesar Millan are currently two of the most popular dog trainers in America, if not in the world. Both

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Victoria Stilwell or Cesar Millan: Who would you call??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

136151

Featured Partner

MENTOR - National Mentoring Partnership

MENTOR has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause. Browse MENTOR's featured titles, p...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA