1 of 103

Yes

Write now Article Tools

I have experienced both home-schooling and public education, and I found I learned far more and tried much harder in home education. Although I found the drawback to home education to be a reduction in social contact, it doesn't have to be that way.

Home education offers less distraction with the ability to work one-on-one with a teacher, be it a parent or a distance education correspondent. Being able to talk to the teacher is a big help; with large classrooms it can be very hard to ensure the quality of everyone's learning. Much of my education was through online correspondence, and worked similarly to a classroom environment without having to deal with the distraction of many other students. I was able to contact all of my teachers through phone and e-mail and they would almost always be available during regular school hours.

By working through Argyll Home School, I used a nearly identical curriculum to the public school system. The difference was a flexibility to work on subjects at leisure. I found that minimally-directed learning helped me learn time management skills essential for college. Of course, my parents were the primary force that kept me focussed on my studies, as you can't expect any elementary student just to sit and do their homework all day.

I entered the public education system for the last two years of high school. The first difficulty I found here was how enforced the learning felt. It seemed that the teachers relied more upon intimidation for students to get their work done. What I found most intimidating was the constant barrage of tests and minor assignments designed to motivate students to read the textbooks. As a studious student, I worked myself into a frenzy trying to keep up with all of the little details and mini assignments due every single class.

By the end of my second year, I had already begun to take an entirely new attitude to learning: avoidance. Most of my new friends also employed the strategy, and I found that students had trouble accepting anyone who is a hard worker, as it makes them feel lesser somehow. Combine a collective attitude with the numbing effect of constant assignments, and my grades began to slip.

Don't ge me wrong, I had to work very hard in home school as well. The difference was that the teachers would provide larger assignments and give students more time to work on them. There were also fewer small tests, so the level of pressure was much lower.

Although the public system seems geared to prepare students

• 1
• 2
• next page >>

Add your voice

Know something about Is homeschooling better than formal education??
We want to hear your view. Write now!