Channel Button

There are 7 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #1 by Helium's members.

Debate_icon

Pets & Animals   >

Dog Training

Get a Widget for this title

Positive reinforcement or correction based training: Which is the better method?

Results so far:

Reinforce
71% 95 votes Total: 134 votes
Correct
29% 39 votes

by Am.

With training, it is important to understand that four types of consequences can happen: positive punishment (add bad thing), positive reinforcement (add good), negative punishment (stop good), and negative reinforcement (stop bad). Dogs, like all animals, are concentrating on survival. Considering that, our pets realize that we have control of the access to important resources like food, toys, walks, etc. The goal of positive reinforcement is to let the animal know that it performed the correct behavior, earning it brief access to a resource.

According to Jean Donaldson's book, "The Culture Clash," there are five important rules to understanding behavior. First, dogs do whatever works. The second rule is presented above, the four kinds of consequences. Third, all of those consequences must be immediate. The good and bad consequences will be associated with the animal's surroundings. Finally, dogs are experts at reading the environment to know which consequences are likely for which behaviors in any given situation. The bottom line is that behavior that is reinforced should increase in frequency.

Therefore, it would be wise to assume that ignoring a problem/undesired behavior while rewarding goal behavior would be the most effective method to training. In human society, we tend to use punishment a lot, though. For example, criminals are sent to prison for their problem behaviors. However, a large number of those punished re-offend. Simply put, this type of "training" does not seem to work well (Donaldson). Examples of punishment in dog training are verbal reprimands, spanking, hitting, spraying with water, leash jerks, etc. Typically, these actions have to be used over and over, and generally, the intensity of the action has to increase. Punishment does NOT stop behavior. It stuns, or interrupts, it. The animal will figure out ways to do the behavior without receiving a punishment. For example, a dog that is punished for urinating in the living room will learn that it is unsafe to urinate in the living room while it's owner is present. Or, if it is punished for urinating while it's owner was at work (the owner did not witness the "crime"), it will learn that the return of it's owner from work is dangerous, which creates fear. This is the potential hazard of punishment-based training. If used inappropriately and ineffectively, it can cause your animal to actively fear YOU. Most of the time, the animal associates the punishment with you and/or the specific occurrences


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Positive reinforcement or correction based training: Which is the better method?

Reinforce
  • 1 of 5

    by Am.

    With training, it is important to understand that four types of consequences can happen: positive punishment (add bad thing),

    read more

  • 2 of 5

    by Barbaraanne Helberg

    Why Positive Reinforcement Works Best in Dog Training

    Dogs are much like small children in their emotional responses. A

    read more

Correct
  • 1 of 2

    by Judy J. Lehrman

    Correct or Reinforce? I don't see how anyone could "train" a dog, or any other animal for that matter, without BOTH!


    I have

    read more

  • 2 of 2

    by Christine Bennett

    My side of the debate took some thinking about because actually this side the correct' side could also be on the reinforce

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Positive reinforcement or correction based training: Which is the better method??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

100501

Featured Partner

Presidential Climate Action Project (PCAP)

The Presidential Climate Action Project (PCAP) has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause....more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA