Where Knowledge Rules

Society & Lifestyle:

Morals, Values & Norms

Debate_icon Get a Widget for this title

Should hanging a noose in public be considered a hate crime?

Results so far:

Yes
58% 286 votes Total: 493 votes
No
42% 207 votes

SIGNS OF INTIMIDATION

Drive through any city in America and you are likely to see all forms of hate. Usually spray painted on overpasses or old buildings. A noose, certainly offers a different perspective, a texture of history which is, for some, not easily forgotten. Less alive than a middle finger, but certainly something that would elicit reaction.

A noose, where I am from would be particularly bothersome due to the history. Four men, who may or may not have been guilty of shooting and killing a federal marshall, were dragged from jail and hanged. Without a trial. Without a judgement. Witnesses never spoke up. The people who hung the four men got away with murder. All of the victims were white men. None were upstanding citizens. There was a history here. This was the place where outlaws came to hide out. They still do, but they are tamed and used. Or they repent. Or they become cops. Or they end up in prison. Or they become better citizens than any church lady could ever hope to be. Something like that.

So, if I walked out my door and saw a noose, more than likely, I wouldn't be thinking in terms of race. No, but I'd have a myriad of possibilities to consider. It would, in no uncertain terms, piss me off.

The noose is old. Older than America and slavery. It did not originate in America. And it is, to be sure, intimidating. When I think of hangings, I think of large groups of people in attendance, watching. Kind of like cattle or pigs. Sickening. The lowest of the low. I do not see it as some romantic notion of justice. I see it as the most cowardly form of anti-human, anti-democracy that man ever construed.

Some folks thrive on the memories of the old west when justice was, many times, dispensed without a trace of logic or any consideration of law. Here's the problem I have with it, any one can be hung. Any one can find themselves dangling from a rope.

Displaying a noose in public is more a form of intimidation. A reminder. As long as it is not used, it is not a crime though.

Just as it is not a crime to voice one's opinion. Certainly, displaying a noose is less dangerous than shooting a bullet into the air. But I'd rather paint a meadow on the side of a building.

I'd rather not be involved with intimidation tactics. Defending oneself is a requirement of survival. Leaving a noose is kind of like leaving a gun.

I'm glad the United States military doesn't donate tanks to the Taliban.

There is this way that humans have of attempting to persuade others to remain within the invisible boundaries.

Learn more about this author, G E Barr.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Should hanging a noose in public be considered a hate crime?

No
  • 1 of 30

    by G E Barr

    SIGNS OF INTIMIDATION

    Drive through any city in America and you are likely to see all forms of hate. Usually spray painted

    read more

  • 2 of 30

    by Jack Merridew

    Hanging a noose is a terrifying act implying threat of execution; however, the simple tying of a rope around a tree or any

    read more

Yes
  • 1 of 25

    by robertsloan2

    Let's look at the context of the noose for whether it's a hate crime. I'm familiar with the recent case in Louisiana that

    read more

  • 2 of 25

    by Rosemary Redfern

    A noose has one function. To strangle a human by the neck until they are dead. A secondary use is trapping animals but

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Should hanging a noose in public be considered a hate crime??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

171851

Featured Partner

Dogs Deserve Better

Dogs Deserve Better has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause. Browse Dogs Deserve B...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA