Channel Button

There are 79 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #1 by Helium's members.

Debate_icon

Education   >

Educational Philosophy

Get a Widget for this title

Is it better for schools to be rigorous or nurturing?

Title endorsed in part by:

Results so far:

Rigorous
45% 327 votes Total: 722 votes
Nurturing
55% 395 votes

by Ory

Rigorous or nurturing schools? The idea of going to a good school and getting a great education is romantic. Most families are enamored of the idea of their children getting a good education and many pay large sums of money for the diploma. Few families love their children enough to allow them to struggle. Yes, struggle, a core course in the curriculum of a great education. Instead, they are lauded with accolades of their inherent value and psalms of their intellectual stature; irreverent of the truth and completely intolerant of any challenge to the ideal of the child's goodness. Heaven help the teacher that dares to hold their students to any standard, much less a standard of excellence.

For the most part, the educational establishment has also embraced this lunacy of hugs over homework, providing graduation ceremonies, including tassels and mortarboards for "graduating" from Kindergarten. The nurture crowd says, "Every child needs a certificate of accomplishment", irreverent of whether the teacher received a single passing assignment all year. We cannot have anyone feeling left out. They need more nurturing not struggling and heaven forbid anyone be expected to dare true accomplishment, that would risk failure and that would shatter our dream, that might make another student feel bad. Not to worry, the administration is regularly there to keep the teachers in line with the parent's wishes to protect the students self image of greatness.

Is it any wonder why our public schools fail to produce students that can pass a standardized test. Strange, SAT scores have dropped year after year, despite more federal regulation and federal money. Our certified teachers have trouble passing basic skills tests to graduate from college with Bachelors in Education. Thankfully, home school and private school teachers are not yet required to become "certified." Is it any wonder this type of indulgence has resulted in our children growing up to be the uneducated teachers we complain about teaching in our schools? Is it any wonder that our "teachers" are no more mature than their students are. Why a sudden increase in the number of teachers charged with having indecent relationships with their students? After all, they are the same age emotionally and they know they deserve to be happy.

But, what is on the other side of the coin? The very things we claim for our children and fail to give them, firstly, accomplishment. How can anyone have genuine self-esteem unless they accomplish


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Is it better for schools to be rigorous or nurturing?

Rigorous
  • 1 of 48

    by Ory

    Rigorous or nurturing schools? The idea of going to a good school and getting a great education is romantic. Most families

    read more

  • 2 of 48

    by American Citizen

    Smooches, honey! Wow you got a "C"! I'm so proud you're average.

    On one hand, it's a false choice between rigor and nurturance.

    read more

Nurturing
  • 1 of 31

    by Elaine Grant

    School can be a frightening, insecure place for many children even those who are average or above average. A child with excellent

    read more

  • 2 of 31

    by Trisha Clark

    I firmly believe school should be a combination of both rigorous training and nurturing the student emotionally. A school

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Is it better for schools to be rigorous or nurturing??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

239125

Featured Partner

American Skating Association

We happen to think skating - in all forms is good for people of most ages. It is the one form of exercise that you ca...more

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA