Where Knowledge Rules

US Politics:

US Elections

Debate_icon Get a Widget for this title

Should outside groups be allowed to file ethics complaints against members of Congress?

Results so far:

No
20% 50 votes Total: 247 votes
Yes
80% 197 votes

Why We Need Independent Oversight Of Congress

The Committee on Standards of Official Conduct generally has jurisdiction to investigate members of Congress and whether or not they have committed an ethics violation such as receiving inappropriate gifts, gifts or money from foreign entities, or bribes from lobbyists. They have many rules regarding the use of free private corporate transportation, vacations that are disguised as fact finding missions, and even rules as to what stock may be owned by a serving member of Congress.

The Committee touts it's many investigations and resolutions of various complaints against House members, but the simple fact is that the Committee has degenerated into little more than a sham that is used not to investigate actual wrongdoing of importance, but as a political weapon of gotcha by both political parties.

Some recent cases that you may or may not have heard of pretty much sums up exactly what the Standards Committee has turned into.

James McDermott gave the N.Y. Times a recording of a telephone conversation between Boehner and Gingrich in which they were discussing how to skew a Congressional investigation into Gingrich's activities, that was recorded by a Florida couple. Using cell phones, Boehner and Gingrich must have known that scanners can pick up the conversations. Whatever the case, the two were discussing what should have amounted to criminal activity, because they were conspiring to interfere with a Congressional oversight committee investigation of Gingrich. What happened instead was a ten year nightmare for McDermott, because he was sued and pursued relentlessly by House Republicans, who demanded the Standards Committee investigate McDermott.

In 2004, the Standards Committee sent Tom DeLay a letter admonishing him for all of his ethics violations, but since sham criminal proceedings were going to take place in Texas, the Committee settled for just slapping DeLay on the wrist. Had DeLay not resigned in disgrace, he could actually still be a member of Congress.

Again in 2004, the Committee gave an admonishment to criminal conduct of House member Nick Smith in the matter of his voting a certain way on the new Medicare Bill in order to gain support for his son's Congressional candidacy. Oh. By the way, DeLay was part of that one also. Admonishment. Not ouster, loss of position, admonishment. Other recent House members who 'got away with it' include John Boehner, Harry Reid, and Charles Rangel.

Then we turn and take a look


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Should outside groups be allowed to file ethics complaints against members of Congress?

Yes
  • by Paul Wylie

    Why We Need Independent Oversight Of Congress

    The Committee on Standards of Official Conduct generally has jurisdiction to

    read more

  • 2 of 16

    by Erin Allen

    The question should more rightly be asked, "When shouldn't outside groups be allowed to file ethics complaints against members

    read more

No
  • 1 of 8

    by Kenneth Boser II

    It seems that while the ethics of Congressmen and Congresswomen deteriorates, there seems to be more and more calls for

    read more

  • 2 of 8

    by Solarfinder

    The minute we follow this slippery slope of politics, we will find our selves in an unrecoverable position. The question,

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Should outside groups be allowed to file ethics complaints against members of Congress? ?
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

Partnerlogo

Featured Partner

Catalyst Music inc

more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA