Channel Button

There are 53 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #2 by Helium's members.

Debate_icon

Sciences   >

Physics

Get a Widget for this title

Is time real or relative?

Results so far:

Relative
69% 631 votes Total: 920 votes
Real
31% 289 votes
2 of 36
Relative

Page 3 of 6

was sent through each notch to the mirror, which reflected back to the same notch, after having rotating one notch over, in front of the lens of a powerful telescope. In short, one pulse of the light signal, traveling over 17.2 km, should be caught within 1/720th of the wheel's rotation. Done at night, the first image would be of a light flashing in the distance. When the wheel's speed is adjusted so that when the light stops flashing and becomes steady, the tachometer is read, and the rest is simple arithmetic.

For the record, Jean-Bernard-Leon Foucault, Fizeau's assistant, repeated the experiment the next year, only using rotating mirrors.

By the time Michelson was studying optics in Europe (1880-82), the speed of light across the Earth's surface was known to such considerable degree of accuracy that it was considered "constant" everywhere, no matter what.

But it remained to be proved how it propagated through the ether.

The theory was that light propagates as rarefactions of the ether much the way sound travels through air, or waves travel on the ocean. If the ether exists, it will be distorted as a drag wake around the Earth as the Earth speeds around the Sun at such a considerable speed (30 kps) that the distortion of the ether should be measurable.

In 1881, Michelson used his first interferometer to look for the effect. He split one beam of light (he called them "pencils of light") through a half-silvered mirror (in the center) into two perpendicular beams sent to two mirrors on each arm of the device, and back to another half-silvered mirror in the center, given focus through a microscope. The instrument was simple at first; two spindly brass arms on a tripod light enough to set on the kitchen table without scratching the surface.

The difference between the light beam traveling ACROSS (transversely) the direction of the Earth's orbit, to the light beam traveling PARALLEL (longitudinally) to the direction of orbit, should throw the two recombined light beams out of phase to produce a measurable interference fringe in the magnitude of:

2(v^2 + c^2) : ((c + v) + (c - v))^2

The amount of fringing predicted would be from the same mechanism that spoils conversation in the back of a speeding pickup truck.

When the device was rotated 90 degrees, the fringe shift should have been still more dramatic, albeit still on a microscopic level.

Instead, Michelson saw NOTHING. At least, nothing beyond the margin of instrument error.

Thinking the error might be caused by the shortness


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Is time real or relative?

Relative
  • 1 of 36

    by Dave Nocera

    Techncially we are all time travelers, sitting at your computer you are moving through time. We are submerged in time and

    read more

  • 2 of 36

    by Joe Murray

    The theory of relative time arose through the six classic pillars of science: a field observation, supporting verifiable

    read more

Real
  • 1 of 17

    by S E Garrett

    All of Reality as we perceive it is Relative Awareness and ambiguous Time, one of the three essential prerequisites for that

    read more

  • 2 of 17

    by Gary C. Gibson

    The inflation of space-time from a zero-dimensional state at the initial singularity was universal time=0. The implicit expansion

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Is time real or relative??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

118457

Featured Partner

Why Tuesday

Why Tuesday has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause. Browse Why Tuesday's featured...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA