Channel Button

There are 19 articles on this title. You are reading the article ranked and rated #6 by Helium's members.

Debate_icon

Health & Fitness   >

Surgery

Should smokers and the obese be denied coronary artery bypass surgery?

Results so far:

No
85% 179 votes Total: 211 votes
Yes
15% 32 votes

I am the person you wanted to kill last month.

On May 25, I had a quadruple bypass operation. It is probable that it was the result of my having smoked for 46 years.

Mind you, there have been other, more dangerous, things that I have done in my life. In the late 1960's I spent a year fighting in Vietnam. In 1970, I covered an explosion at the Humble Oil refinery in Linden, NJ - after signing a release because of the possibility of further blasts. In 1982, when the Israeli Army fought the PLO in Lebanon, I went in with it as a reporter. In 2006, I spent 34 days living on a kibbutz literally meters from the Lebanese border as Hizbollah fired rockets at us.

I escaped all of these without injury but the cigarettes got me. For that reason, if you had your way, I would have been allowed to die.

It is not important to you that I have two children. No, you would leave them without a father for my sin of having gotten addicted to nicotine as a teenager.

It doesn't matter to you that my 91-year-old mother would have had to bury her son. In fact, you might well feel that it would be a fair punishment for her - as she has smoked for over 70 years with no heart problems at all.

The pleasure that I like to think that I have brought to people worldwide with the humor and satire columns that I have written over the years would stop. That, too, is of little import to you - after all, they should not smile at words written by a smoker.

Perhaps you object to the death penalty for murderers and rapists. You feel that it is a cruel punishment and, after all, violent criminals are human beings, too. The death penalty for smokers, however, seems very fair in your eyes.

Who else, I wonder, should die in order to meet your particular sense of morality? I note that you would include the obese - even though many of them are not overweight because of their dietary habits.

Perhaps you feel that American soldiers who are injured in battle should not receive medical aid - it is a volunteer army and they could have chosen not to enlist.

You might want to deny medical treatment to anyone with a sexually transmitted disease. True, they may have been infected by their husbands or wives, but they were not required to have sex at all.

Someone who is in an automobile accident may, in your eyes, also be turned away from hospitals. Who forced him to be in the car in the first place?

The best part of all of this, of course, is that your health insurance premiums will go down. With the money that you save at the cost of the lives of others, you could make your life much more pleasurable. Indeed, you might save up enough over the years to buy that boat that you have long wanted. Of course, should it capsize at sea, don't expect the Coast Guard to save you. You chose to sailing - and it would be a tremendous waste of money to send ships and helicopters to pull you out of the ocean.

Learn more about this author, Josh Wilde.
Contact this writer Click here to send author comments or questions.


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Should smokers and the obese be denied coronary artery bypass surgery?

No
  • 1 of 16

    by Jon Dainty Sr.

    Reading this might be a temporary escape from reality. There are still people who believe that "personal responsibil...read more

  • 2 of 16

    by Renee Dawson

    Perhaps it can be said that the last prejudice is against those who are overweight. I know a woman who is overweight...read more

Yes
  • 1 of 3

    by John Graham

    Certainly! Smokers should be denied all insurance protection for any medical condition, such as coronary arterial byp...read more

  • 2 of 3

    by Jonathan Carney

    Coronary artery bypass surgery is a surgical procedure carried out to relieve angina and reduce the risks of coronary...read more

Add your voice

Know something about Should smokers and the obese be denied coronary artery bypass surgery??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

Difference of opinion? Debate now.
Surgery
Gastric bypass surgery: Is it safe?
173917

Featured Partner

Takes All Types

Takes All Types has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause. Browse Takes All Types' f...more

What is Helium? | User Guide | Community | Link to Helium | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA