Where Knowledge Rules

Society & Lifestyle:

Ethnicity & Gender

Debate_icon Get a Widget for this title

Does biology or society have a stronger influence on the development of our gender identity?

Results so far:

Biology
41% 209 votes Total: 509 votes
Society
59% 300 votes

Society and biology play a big part of how we identify ourselves as men and women but one plays a bigger part than the other. Biology plays a role in how we develop anatomically but society plays a role in how we develop psychologically. Society's influence is a lot stronger on how we identify with our gender. Before a baby is born, the sex is determined; and based off of that sex parents make plans of what they imagine their little tike to be doing once they can walk and talk. They are already designated by two colors, blue and pink.

If you watch children channels such as Nickelodeon or Cartoon Network, during the commercial break, advertisements such as Lego never have little girls in them. The same thing goes for advertisements for Barbie and baby dolls. I can honestly say I have never seen boys in these commercials with the exception of the Ken doll of course. If there were commercials of little boys playing with baby dolls it would most likely cause uproar in the community. Items like Easy Bake Oven are primarily targeted to little girls and Hot Wheels are targeted towards little boys. Can boys not like to bake? Can girls not like to race? Men and women are taught from very young what they are supposed to like.

Society believes that men are supposed to be the bread winners of the home and the women are supposed to be the supporter and homemaker. Men are supposed to be masculine and women feminine. In the dictionary feminine is defined as being "of or suitable for women, having qualities or appearance considered characteristic of a woman" and masculine is defined as being "of or like or suitable for men, having the qualities or appearance considered characteristic of a man". Men are expected to be aggressive, active, competitive, strong, etc. Women are expected to be gentle, loving, nurturing, sweet, soft spoken, etc. This definitely does not come from biology.

A lot of people say that the characteristics of a woman and man come from the hormones that are present in their bodies. Truth be told, both men and women have estrogen and testosterone obviously women have lesser levels of testosterone and men lesser levels of estrogen so it is not biology. Traditionally society has the notion that men are the hunters and women the preparers of the hunt which is where the term "bringing home the bacon" comes from.

It could not be biology that influences our gender identity, because if so how do you explain men who are not aggressive or active and are soft spoken and


Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:

Does biology or society have a stronger influence on the development of our gender identity?

Society
  • 1 of 21

    by Angie Haggstrom

    Society, rather than biology, is the main determining factor in defining one's gender identity. Biological make up and physical

    read more

  • 2 of 21

    by John Winter

    The question of where our identity comes from is age old, but put in certain contexts the answers can be much simpler than

    read more

Biology
  • 1 of 16

    by Dambrath

    The nature vs nurture discussion has been raging for decades now as to which has the greater influence over us, how we develop

    read more

  • 2 of 16

    by Yehuda Harmor

    I used to believe that gender (as opposed to sex) was almost entirely due to socialisation. Some friends with children thought

    read more

Add your voice

Know something about Does biology or society have a stronger influence on the development of our gender identity??
We want to hear your view. Write_penWrite now!

136238

Featured Partner

Environment Northeast (ENE)

Environment Northeast (ENE) has partnered with Helium, giving you the chance to write for a cause. Browse ENE's ...more

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA