Home > Politics, News & Issues > News > People in the News
Created on: May 30, 2008
Two years after leaving the Bush White House, Scott McClellan has joined the ranks of the unbelievers, writing a "tell-all" memoir about the run-up to the war in Iraq, the Valerie Plame scandal, and the propaganda machine running the whole business. The reaction has been fairly predictable as current White House staffers have leaped to the President's defense and McClellan has already been called a traitor on FOX News at least half a dozen times, well before anyone could actually have read and assimilated the book itself.
Speculation has run rampant too on why McClellan would write such a testimony; some have claimed he's bitter about the circumstances of his departure, others that he just wanted to exploit the profit margin inherent in this kind of controversy. No one seems to believe that he feels he is doing the right thing by chronicling the deceitful practices used by the administration, but even if that were the case, McClellan's book comes as too little, too late.
Unless the final chapters of the book offer some surprise that the pundits haven't gotten to yet, McClellan's book tells us nothing that we didn't already know. President Bush decided to go to war in Iraq well before the subject was broached in the public media. Facts were twisted in aid of that goal, and the news media was discouraged from asking real questions about it. And the administration at the very least covered up its role in the leaking of CIA operative Valerie Plame's identity. Bloggers and the occasional minor news outlet have been discussing these subjects since 2003. Sorry, Scott, no one's surprised.
Because, you see, it isn't that people don't know what happened, it's that they don't seem to care. McClellan's book only serves to point out, once again, one of the biggest problems in current American politics: that only scandal gets press time, never the issues. While this would be an excellent opportunity for the major news media to discuss the possibility that there is something seriously wrong with the way this country is being run, or to face up to their own complicity in the Iraq War, instead we hear only about McClellan's "disloyalty" and supposed mercenary impulses. It's a shameful reaction, but not a surprising one. As long as the media can continue to get away with promoting scandal and controversy instead of addressing the issues at hand, this book will only destroy one reputation - Scott McClellan's, whether he deserves it or not.
Learn more about this author, Jen Moore.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:
Commentary: Former press secretary Scott McClellan writes nasty tell-all book
If you haven't read the book, as most of us have not, we take our cues from others who happen to know something about the
Former Press Secretary Scott McClellan's tell-all book was not an attempt to set the record straight, or to provide historians
by Ted Sherman
It could have been a Star Trek scenario, except in this case, the captain would groan, "Why are you beaming me down, Scotty."
Scott McClellan writes a nasty book for personal gain. This is nothing that should surprise anyone if you know the man's
Though tell all books are nothing new, this is a story that needed to be told. Imagine standing in front of the nation assuring
View All Articles on: Commentary: Former press secretary Scott McClellan writes nasty tell-all book
Helium Debate
Cast your vote!
Should the US pose an excise tax on BP to pay for the Gulf oil spill cleanup?
Click for your side.
Featured Partner
Sunshine Week is a nonpartisan, good-government effort led by the American Society of Newspaper Editors, but with a constituency that goes beyond print, broadcast and online news media to include students of all ages; federal, state and ...more