Home > Creative Writing > Reflections
Created on: April 24, 2008 Last Updated: March 10, 2009
In today's increasingly visual world, many people - especially teenagers - have forsaken reading or have severely reduced their book consumption. It is not due to a dislike of the stories, but rather a preference for a more appropriate - to them - medium. After all, a movie is on average a two-hour time commitment, while a good book can take days or more to read; in a movie, our visual sense is entertained and stimulated as we see the explosions, crashes, and drama on the big screen, while in a book it is our imagination that is utilized. Some people prefer the up-front excitement, while others prefer the deep connection that only books can create.
It's important to realize that there is no right or wrong side to this argument. To certain people, books are uninteresting, plain and simple. Often time, we book-lovers become arrogant and think that our way is the best way and that everyone else is simply not as motivated as we are. We should avoid this line of thinking and instead realize that each person requires and thrives on a different form of learning and entertainment.
Nonetheless, as I said earlier, I am an avid book reader who unequivocally believes in the power and knowledge that books can provide to even the most infrequent of readers. In the written world of literature, we can embark on any sort of journey that our mind is willing to travel; like movies, there are action, adventure, drama, comedy, satirical, romance, and many more kinds of novels. Unlike movies, though, books allow a true connection to the story at hand; you sympathize more with the characters, you love when they love, hurt when they hurt, and a part of you dies when they do.
Perhaps it sounds overdramatic or pathetic, but it's true. Not all readers develop this intense of a connection, but many do, and the ones that have it understand how difficult it is to explain.
Still, there are occasions in which the movie does actually outshine its novel counterpart. Some novels can drag a bit at times, or even have too much information for the reader to sufficiently follow. At times like these, movies are a better medium to be able to express a theme or story. As a whole, though, I think it is impossible for me to state anything other than the fact that I believe that written literature is far and away the better of the two options. Still, it's not for everyone. Until you are absolutely certain, though, try picking up a book or two and give it the old college try, eh? You might be surprised by what you find.
Learn more about this author, Michael Mikolajczyk.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Below are the top articles rated and ranked by Helium members on:
Reflections: Reading a book vs. watching a movie
Do you prefer your own dreams or those of someone else? Reading stimulates the creative area of the mind to produce
In the argument of reading a book versus watching a movie there is no right or wrong. With matters of opinion there is no
by Elmare Aldum
An escape from reality where imagination rules the day, this can be found between the pages of a book or the visual and
by Ruby Jinga
As an avid book-lover, I would say read the book first, then watch the movie. I love both mediums but have always enjoyed
by Robin Landry
Like the singer Jewel in her hit song "Intuition" I feel that, "I'm just a simple girl in a high tech digital world." As
View All Articles on: Reflections: Reading a book vs. watching a movie
Featured Partner
Founded in January 2006, the mission of the Sunlight Foundation is to strengthen the relationship between lawmakers and their constituents by maximizing transparency of the work of Congress, its members, staff and lobbyists. Sunlight bel...more