Title endorsed in part by:
Results so far:
| No | 9% | 21 votes | Total: 237 votes | |
| Yes | 91% | 216 votes |
In todays modern world, should anyone be subject to such harsh and painful work? Is working in a mine considered forced labor or slavery? The answer is a simple no. Miners around the country are in fact a large part of our countries industry and their safety is a concern, but government intervention into mines would be another example of Americas slow and slippery decline into a world of complete authoritarian rule. I do not, in any way, believe that the government of the United States should place stricter regulations and more rigorous inspections into the mines of this country.
Miners are not manipulated or enslaved to go into the mines. They work completely due to free will and realize the dangers that a mine shaft presents on a daily basis. They realize and acknowledge the possibility of a mine shaft collapse, or a machinery accident could possibly happen at any time of their working hours. Miners are not bonded nor manipulated to be put into these harsh and rough conditions, they do so in order to help support their families and selves. Miners work completely on free will and I am sure that they acknowledge the dangers that are presented in their work.
Accidents will always happen, whether the government steps up safety standards or inspections. To say otherwise, is pure ignorance and absolute stupidity. Accidents not only happen in mines, but in offices, houses, streets, sidewalks, bathrooms, and a myriad of other locations across the globe. Must we raise safety standards and inspections to sidewalk construction? Must we raise safety standards and inspections to your homes, vehicles, and yards? Must we regulate all things considered dangerous to the American public on a monthly, weekly, or daily basis? The gate to Big Brother surely will have swept open! Soon a book is dangerous for children to read, so by regulations, lets burn the copies. A book is dangerous to the establishment of the American Government, lets burn it. It is a sad, sadistic spiral that will eventually consume all aspects of American life. Accidents will always happen, and things will always be slightly unsafe, but that does not mean the government should come in and regulate everything deemed as such.
The government, with a extremely large defiect, does not have the money to create a department solely on this concern. The American government has more concerns then the mine shafts of the US considering they have been running effectively for so many years and have helped our economy for so long. The American government should be more concerned with the poor economic status, the lack of health care for American citizens, a war started completely on falsified information that is completely disagreed with by the public, and the corrupt members of congress and the white house itself. The last thing that I would prefer our government to do is to worry about free-willed miners, whom acknowledge the dangers of the profession they have chosen, who are unsafe or in harms way. And it is even more of a pity that the pure ignorance of American democrats to focus on such.
Mines should not be subject to stricter safety standards nor more rigorous inspections. This is a matter of power, whether disguised as safety or the increase of moral fiber in America. Their is an old saying that proclaims that absolute power corrupts absolutely, and we are slowly giving them complete and total power over Americans. Our founding fathers who fought against the monarchy of the English would truely be rolling in their graves at such a pitiful and ignorant thought. And I surely will as well.
Learn more about this author, Jake Dalton.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
This debate comes down to two things: values and equality. What do we, as a modern society value? Is it human lives? No, just look at the Iraq War. Is it international trade? No, look at the USA's trading actions with Mexico and Canada. Is it being accountable on the world stage? No, look at the sponsorship scandal. We as citizens wish these were the things we value, but they are not. Instead, the immense greed of humans has taken over the ideals that we've been raised with. Do we support full equality among people? No, our economy is based on the very principal that all are not equal. What terrible project could epitomize these corrupt values we have? The answer very well might be on your spouse's hand. That ring you gave them many years ago was mined, and it is only now that these transnational mining companies are being called to account. But it is not the governments addressing this issue, it is our people.
Imagine the face of a young child who wakes up in the morning to find part of his house broken in by a flying stone excavated by some miners. This is not an uncommon occurrence in countries with mineral rich landscapes. Companies want to get to whatever they're mining for as fast as they can, with as little regard for anything besides their own profit.
Look at the environmental factors that result from these disastrous open-pit mines. Trees must be uprooted, and no forest will ever grow again in this raped land. Some extremely fertile soil that could be used for crops is destroyed. Not to mention the extreme amount of fossil fuels needed to operate the mining machinery, transport the excavated materials and fly people in and out of these foreign areas.
Not just governments, but the companies themselves should create better standards, and start to respect human lives, equality for both workers as well as local citizens. The CEOs of such corporation should think about what they would want if a foreign company came in and started destroying the natural beauty of their backyards. Foreign miners must be called to account for their actions and we should not relent until laws and standards are put into effect to restore the values humanity should truly prioritize.
Learn more about this author, Lime Blue Cube.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.