Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Health & Fitness   >

Health Care

Get a Widget for this title

Do nursing homes help people get well or prepare them to die?

Results so far:

Die
79% 347 votes Total: 442 votes
Get well
21% 95 votes
Die

I voted no for one reason, and that is because most people never get out of the Nursing home once they're in there. In this day and age, we have more assisted living places to help the ones who are able to still function on their own with minimul assist. When they can no longer do enough on their own to meet certain criteria, then they are sent to the Nursing home for total care.

I have worked both sides, and before we got the assisted living built on, everyone went to the nursing home side, but some were there to recuperate from broken hips, strokes, etc. So a lot of them did get to go home. Some got increasingly worse, so they remained there for the duration of their lives.

We also had a lot of patients that had slight dementia, what some use to call senility, and it eventually went into advancing Alzheimer's. One side of the nursing home was set up as an Alzheimer's unit with special care and security measures.

I've already lost four of my aunts and uncles with Alzheimer's, so I know how it progresses. Most of them eventually get sent to locked Alzheimer's units at another more advanced facility. It's a heartbreaking disease and there is no cure. Hopefully there will be somedsy.

A lot of people really get upset at the very thought of going to live with those "OLD" people, as they call them. They just don't feel that they're ready to be put in a place like that. It's just as hard on the caring families as it is the resident.

And it would be hard. You raised your family. You payed off your retirement home, and now you can no longer live there because you have health problems from getting on in years. Isn't retiring what you have worked for all of your life? This is what it has come to.

A lot of the elderly people feel that the family doesn't want to be bothered anymore, which isn't true in most cases. But after a patient has fallen two or three times at home, being at home alone, is not an option. Eventually something gets broken, and it's usually a hip requiring surgery and recuperation. Some patients are so traumatized from the fall, that they fear walking and some never walk again.

Most nursing homes are equipped with re-habilitation aides under the supervision of a Physical Therapist. Therapy, such as range of motion, is done daily on each patient requiring therapy. Ambulation is important to keep the patient up and going. No one wants to wind up in a wheel chair any sooner than they have to.

Surprisingly enough, a lot of people really like the care, the attention, the security of knowing that there is always someone around. They have activities, singspirations, parties. Some don't even realize how lonely they are until they're around people again. In a small town like I live in, everybody knows everyone else anyway. It all works out in the end.

Yes, for some, it is the end of the line, and the end of their life, but for some, it is the beginning of a new phase in their lives. I saw people come and I saw them go. It's always a blessing to see someone get to go home, even if it's only for a short period of time.

Nursing homes take away a lot of dignity. Not on purpose, but in everyday living. Some need to be showered, dressed, taken to the toilet, fed their meals. All the things that they did for themselves all their lives. Those generations were very modest.

They grew up in modesty. They were taught to be dignified in their apparell, in the way they lived. That's who they were. Now they are taken to the shower, stripped of all clothing and exposed to the very thing that they have never known. A stranger seeing them naked. Some have to endure someone cleaning up an accident they had. How humiliating for them. Most of them get use to it after awhile. They have accepted the way it has to be. Some never stop fighting it.

A lot of it has to do with the caretaker. The way a patient is treated is what they are going to respond to. I use to just talk to them about things I knew they were interested in. If only to keep their mind off of what was going on. It actually works as long as you don't make them feel inhibited.

People need to live with dignity and they need to die with dignity. They need to feel a spiritual atmosphere because for most of them, this is their last stop before they go on to a better place.

We're all going to be there some day, and I'd like to think that I will be treated the way I treated people in their care. Don't inflict on others what you, yourself, wouldn't want to feel. The way they get treated makes them decide whether or not they really want to stay.

Learn more about this author, Candy Jules.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Get well

Nursing home. Those two words immediately conjure depressing visions of frail, decrepit people, slumped over in wheelchairs. People stuck in a form of limbo, unable to live in the real world, but not ready to pass on to the next. They are the old and forgotten, left at the nursing home to die, because they no longer play a valuable part in society.




In reality aging is a difficult process for many, filled with transitions and losses. One of the most difficult losses is the loss of independence and the inability to care for oneself. The greatest fear of many people, old or young, is ending up in a nursing home, and that fear is perpetuated by negative stereotypes, such as the one above.




Contrary to popular belief, not every old person will end up in a nursing home. Only a very small percentage of the population will end up living at one of these facilities. Society views nursing homes as a place old people go to die, and in a way this is true. Most people frail enough to need 24 hour nursing care are not going to get better and go home, but it also does not mean they are ready to die. Many older adults live happy, productive lives at nursing homes, filling their last years with meaning.




Many of these nursing homes, or skilled nursing facilities, as most are called now, strive to provide their residents with home like environments that make the residents feel comfortable and consider the facility their home. Skilled nursing facilities provide activities for the residents to participate in on a daily basis, such as exercise, art classes and outings. For many older adults, the increase in attention and social interaction with people in their similar situation is very comforting and therapeutic. For many people who had been living at home, their TV may have been their only activity and family members their only social interaction. The nursing services provide residents with 24 hour medical supervision, which keep the people healthier for longer. Many skilled nursing facilities also provide therapy services to help residents maintain their maximum level of independence.




With this understanding of what a modern nursing home is, it becomes clear that the goal is not to provide a place for an older person to go to die, but rather a place where an older person who is no longer able to care for him or herself can be provided with the highest quality of life possible. With the extra care and services a person may stay at a much higher level of independence than he or she would have been able to at home, which has a direct impact on a person's mood and outlook on life.




A skilled nursing facility is another transition in life. For some residents entering the facility, the nursing care and therapy will allow them to gain enough strength to return home or to an assisted living. For other residents the facility will provide a quality of life that may not have been attainable at home, and in that higher quality, make the end years of their lives worthwhile and meaningful.

Learn more about this author, Mindy Hunter.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA