Home > Arts & Humanities > Writing > Business of Writing > Marketing & Selling Writing
Results so far:
| No | 71% | 393 votes | Total: 553 votes | |
| Yes | 29% | 160 votes |
No
Created on: August 15, 2009
Publish America has been one huge disappointment for many would be authors, including me. Like so many other people being new to writing, new to Internet scams, new to publishing I set myself up for failure with Publish America. I had thought myself lucky to have avoided the so called vanity press publishing companies. You know what, if they advertise they are a vanity press or a self publisher at least they are being honest. Publish America sells a lot of hype and uses all the carefully worded sales pitches it takes to lure the writer in.
Being an honest person I still believed that an ethical company would not accept a book just to trap the writer into spending money. I thought they would read the story, send it back with editing or re-writes and help a writer produce a market worthy book. They are a traditional publishing company so, of course, they want the highest quality of book unlike those vanity presses; imagine how people feel when they realize the truth.
My book was a story inspired by an actual event but my creative mind took the story into conspiracy, murder and intrigue. Publish America said it was worthy of publishing. They sent me the contract and I had a local attorney look it over. The attorney said it was very vague but not bad. So I signed it, I have been trying to get them to let me out of the contract for several months now or at least get them to edit my book! The impasse is I can't sell the book in the current status, not edited; they won't let me out of the contract because they say it is marketable as is.
From all the email contacts with Publish America while working on the book I had been duped into believing they were actually editing my book. I had edited with spell check, grammar check and had friends read it. I sent in hundreds of change/errors as I tried to edit my own writing per Publish America's instructions. Still I assumed it would have a final edit by the "real" editor for the company. I never dreamed that a big publishing company would allow material full of errors out with their name on the cover!
Publish America is not a traditional publishing company. This company feeds off thousands of writers, would be writers as well as a few pretty good authors. The business is sign them up and get them to pay Publish America's inflated book prices plus not get any royalties on books purchased by the author. The books are so riddled with typo's and errors they are not suitable for serious marketing by anyone. Even in my small town the local bookstore owner had already had her fill of Publish America's books, she did allow me to have book signing but as time passed, ultimately, I became embarrassed by how pitiful my book was edited, I stopped trying to sell it.
The story line is good, people liked it and not all the readers are people known to me that purchased my book. My book has over 300 errors, mostly commas, some misplaced words and still a few misspelled words. I had a man go through it line by line, page by page, to prove my point. I asked that Publish America make the changes and they flatly refused in an arrogant note back to me. They told me that all books have mistakes in them even best selling authors make mistakes.
My own personal press releases on-line have had a combined total of almost a thousand hits but as far as I can tell no books were so sold. The publisher's reputation alone makes your book difficult to impossible to market. The price is enough to keep any sane person from purchasing most Publish America author's books. You can purchase hard back books from many companies for under $10.00 in all kinds of stores. Most paperback books of unknown authors don't rate a double digit price tag.
My 185 page book is priced from $19.97 to over $20 for tiny paper back, available from on-line sources only.( I challenge anyone to find the book in stock in any book store, it just doesn't happen with a Publish America book.) The book came out March 2008 my largest royalty check has been $46.00 and that, with the first check of $2.79, puts me in the hole by nearly a $1000.00. Just do the math and remember that they say they are the fastest growing publisher in America.
As an author with Publish America you have no way to know if or when a book is sold or where it was sold. They do not market, they use a so called press release that goes no where, that is the extent of their marketing, plus a web page on their site.( Who would go to Publish America to find a book, only family or friends?) Save your self some grief, check out all the negative sites about publishing companies, sorry, Publish America is just one of many scams out there.
If you have been duped by Publish America send a complaint to the Attorney General of Maryland as well as your own state. Send a complaint to the Better Business Bureau in Baltimore, Maryland. The more voices the faster we can get something done about this scam. Publish America has a mean side and they are not above pulling all kinds of dirty tricks on authors that want out of the contracts.
The contract is a seven year agreement worded carefully in favor of Publish America. Novice writers do not see the opportunity to use the vaguely worded agreement against them but it is a carefully devised tool for Publish America to use in case there is dissent and disagreement.
Always do your homework before you sign a contract. Many of us didn't and we are paying for it now. The best advice is stay away from Publish America!
Learn more about this author, S. Linda Jensen.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Yes
Created on: November 22, 2009
My book was published with PA. Every question that I had was answered right away. The first book I submitted was a children's book, and they couldn't provide illustrations, so I just let that go. I thought about self publishing, but these companies want way to much money. I do think that the rumor that PA publishes just about everyone is true, because my first book I sent in was not very good at all. PA makes dreams come true for new beginning authors.
Do i think that veteran writers, and professional writers should go with PA? The answer would be no, because they are pretty slow processing, and getting your book done. I mean, it's taken 2 months to edit my short story, and still no proofs. I don't know how well their marketing is, if there is any at all, but most of these scam alerts on the Internet bashing them is more of people being lazy, and expecting to get everything free, and not promote anything. Some authors expect to sit on the couch, and not lift a finger to sale their own work.
You hear about the "Atlanta Nights" hoax all the time, on every forum, and complaint. All I have to say is look at how many authors that had, and still are going with PA as their publisher. If you look on the internet, their is a scam report for just about every company there is. I certainly don't want to spend thousands of dollars on subsidy companies, and these authors are complaining over spending a couple hundred dollars on their books to promote, which PA clearly says that you're not obligated to do. Like any business, it is trying to make money. They publish your book for free, what do you expect?
I do think the $1.00 advance is a bit embarrassing, but at least they give you something as a new author, and they also send a nice letter with it. I can see how this could be a scam, because I've seen a lot of them, but they have never asked for my credit card, or anything, and not to mention some of the celebrities that have signed with PA, that is something nobody ever mentions. The screenwriter for the movie "The Amityville Horror" is an author with PA.
PA treats their authors with professionalism, and respect, and they have proven that to me, but you have to be patient with their process, because they are accepting, and working on a bunch of crappy, and good books out there, lol. Have you tried to be accepted by a fanxy publishing company. You will need money, an agent, a almost perfect book, and great odds to be accepted. PA is not a vanity press, or a subsidy company. Yes, the books are a little higher on their website, but their making money back for developing the book. The royalties are not the best percentages in the world, but how can you complain with a free process.
I will tell you a true scam is poetry.com. They will accept your work, and send you a generic certificate, so you feel all professional, and then they will try to sell you stuff with your poem on it. I know this, because I told my cousin that I got a certificate for being poet of the year 2007, and she said she got one like that too, which was so embarrassing considering that I told a lot of people about it. That company is messed up, plus I called the lady, and she cursed at me in a foreign accent.
PA has not gave me a reason to talk bad about them. You hear bad stories, and you hear good stories, but 40.000 authors, and only a few bad forums out there, it's not that bad. You can check Wal-mart on the ripoff report. The Internet is somewhere people are going to vent on things. PA accepts your work, they create it free, you got to sell it. That's the terms in the contract. If you want to be a lazy fool, then spend a couple thousand dollars, and let the companies do everything for you. I can tell some authors never worked a day in their life, because they will spend all their day complaining on the Internet about the dumbest things possible.
I mean there was a lady calling the police, because a fast food chain didn't give her a hamburger. You should try PA, it's not like their contract says that their going to eat you up, and spit you out, and take your whole life. It's a basic contract. Here the pro's and con's that are factual, and not what some complainer out there is blowing.
Publish America PROS
Communication
FREE
Will accept about any work you send them
A small gift of $1, which is more likely to be framed then cashed, but the check has an eagle on it, and the statue of liberty which is attractive.
Author has options
There are books from PA that are sold on Barnes & Nobel, Waldenbooks, Amazon. If you type Publish America, you will see.
Will publish short stories at 4.000 words, which most companies want 15.000 words or more, or poetry books of 50 poems or more for FREE
Their cover designs are amazing
They set up book signings for you
Provides you with a website of your own, and it's pretty user friendly, but kind of cheap looking
Forums, with other actual authors talking positively about PA
Thousands of testimonials
They make your dreams of being a first time author come true
They stay in business even though winers keep complaining all the time.
They are willing to publish a crappy book "Atlanta Nights" risking their business to make a dream come true, you got to respect that.
Publish America's CONS
Advance is embarrassing
Their phone number is always tied up, and their message mailbox is always full
I highly doubt they actually read your book, they probably just scan over it.
They use automatic messages to you sometimes, which is annoying.
When ordering a book on their website. Their is some insecure items on the payment page, which is at risk of a high jacker stealing your information. (Kind of strange)
They are slower than a turtle at getting your proofs back, and developing a book.
They feed you some stupid lines about having to pay $45.00 to get your book at the front of the production line, so your book will be published faster, in which after you tell them no, they constantly say your book is almost done.
They send you an e-mail wanting you to buy your own books at a discount.
They do not offer you a complimentary book
Their contract is 7 years long
Sometimes they will never reply to your e-mails if your mean, or you ask a brilliant question
The website they offer you looks pretty generic.
Their editing department is questionable
There reputation from haters on-line is not very good obviously
Book prices are inflated
Royalties are kind of low
You have to promote and market your own book
They do provide illustrations, but for like $500.00 or more
They do come off as a scam at first
They don't have the most brilliant staff in the world, but they are nice
I have seen PA administrators on-line make fun of some authors complaining on their message boards.
PA has flaws like every company has. If you are a first time broke author like myself. I would recommend this company, but if you have enough money to self publish with Lulu.com or author house, you should go with that route. If you just want a book in your name, and it's free. PA is a perfect solution as well. I'm pretty excited about my first book with PA, but I would never send in a novel, because their service is too slow. I would just send in short stories.
Learn more about this author, Joseph Sturgill Jr..
Click here to send this author comments or questions.