My Helium | Join | Log in Where Knowledge Rules

Health & Fitness:

Medical Issues

Debate_icon

RSS RSS Feed

Get a Widget for this title

Should each generation save for their own retirement health care needs?

Title endorsed in part by:

Results so far:

No
29% 25 votes Total: 85 votes
Yes
71% 60 votes
No

In a modern, rich country there should be good health care for everyone, no matter the age, social status or income. I know that many Americans think that that's impossible, but they only think that because they don't know the facts about many other countries. I live in Australia and we have a very good national health care system. Everyone is covered for the important things and we only need to pay small amounts ourselves for a doctor's visit or medicines. And those on a minimal income don't even pay those "gaps". Also the older and old people get all the necessary health care and when they need a nursing home they can get a place there and get taken care of.

You wonder how we finance that? Everyone with an income pays a certain percentage of their income, which means that rich people pay more than the poor. The rich can easily afford that, so this is a very fair system. And with this also the people without an income and all children are covered. The only requirement is that you are an Australian resident.

Why should older people need to pay for their own health care? What happened with the solidarity principle? What happened with the young people taking care of the older ones? What happened with respect to the older generation? Everyone who votes "yes" to this statement should be ashamed of their selfish, self-centered attitude. For what would happen with those who simply can't save for their retirement because they can hardly make ends meet before that? Will you just let them die as soon as they have reached 65 and get sick?

The civilization of a society can be measured by the way they take care of their old, sick and disabled people. Do you want the USA to be such an uncivilized country?

Learn more about this author, Rixta Francis.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Yes

If each generation, even each individual, isn't responsible for their own retirement health care needs, then they have no incentive to take care of their health, nor do they have a reason to save for the care they will need.

The problem of high health care costs is a simple one of supply and demand. There is a lot of demand for health care services because people live unhealthy lives, for the most part. That drives up the price. What makes the situation worse is that nearly everyone thinks someone else is paying for their health care.

Those who have no insurance tend to go to the emergency room to see a doctor. This is the most expensive way to receive attention, but the cost is passed along to everyone else in the form of higher prices. So, even though it's an inconvenience, the poor who don't pay have no strong incentive to avoid situations that lead to sickness or injury.

At the other end of the spectrum is the Medicare patient. They, too, have little incentive to save or do without expensive treatments because they pay only a small portion of the cost. So they want to get everything they're entitled to, with little concern that it is driving up the cost of service for everyone else.

The same situation holds true for those who buy insurance or have employee benefits. "Get it while you can!" seems to be their motto. Although many problems can be avoided by simply losing some weight, it's easier to have knee replacement or bariatric surgery or whatever the doctor offers to remedy the symptoms, for example.

Finally, there is the doctor, with more paperwork to do to comply with third party payers and HMOs. All this paper shuffling has to be done by employees and it adds to the doctor's cost of providing service to patients. It may also take time away from the doctor's treatment of patients.

A simple answer to cutting the rising cost of health care is for each individual to take responsibility for doing everything they can to stay fit and healthy. I realize this goes against every social cue we receive from government and the people who surround most of us, but I also know from experience that it works. The key to cut the cost of health care is to reduce the demand for it.

It seems only natural that people should prefer to be healthy instead of sick or injured. Somehow, over the decades that Medicare or employer-provided health plans have intruded into the doctor/patient relationship, we have been tricked into thinking that we must have some type of health insurance, rather than focusing on making sure we stay as healthy and safe as possible through our own efforts.

I have found that, with some daily attention to healthy exercise and nutrition, I am better off saving cash for my rare health care needs, rather than paying month after month for services I may not ever need. To this end, a Medical Savings Account, is the ideal tax-free solution to the need for the average person's health care needs.

Learn more about this author, Paul Kemp.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA