RSS Feed
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to Favorites
Contact this writerShould children have cell phones at school?
Yes
YES! I believe our kids should have cell phones with them at all times. While in school, however, the phones should either be "off" or silenced in order to not cause interruptions.
I have my seven-year-old daughter take a cell phone to school for various reasons:
I am concerned about something bad happening to my daughter while in school, at a friend's house or on the school bus. I want her to be able to call 911 at a moment's notice, because I don't trust anyone else to keep her safe like I can. 911 still is not an absolute assurance of safety, but a whole lot better than a teacher, other parent or school bus driver alone.
Imagine something like the Amish school shooting incident or the Virginia tech shooting why did nobody call 911 immediately because nobody had direct access to a cell phone, perhaps?
I told my daughter to hide and call 911 if any bad person enters the school or classroom, if there is any kind of emergency on the way back from school or if perhaps she's at a friend's house and she wants to come home, because some "sick" individual scared her with sexual advances (that has never happened, but who knows what could happen!)!
My daughter has her cell phone for only one reason, and that is personal safety!
As for concerns about additional distracting cell phone functions like texting, Internet access and the like: "What keeps you parents from providing your kids with a very BASIC cell phone WITHOUT those features?"
The phone my daughter has, is a military standard rugged phone, and the company I get service from lets you choose certain features for each separate phone line/cell phone on your account. My daughter has only regular calling, including call waiting, caller ID and voice mail. Yes, she can receive text messages, but can only reply with pre-selected answers like "yes", "no", "cancel" and "Can I call you later?"
Besides, she knows that she is being held responsible for each and every phone call she makes. Therefore she usually places no calls to anyone but my husband and I. She knows that if she wants to call friends, she can do that from our house phone with limited supervision.
And if your kids don't stay within the boundaries you set, with all respect, you may want to reconsider your parenting style. It's not the cell phones that are the problem; it's the parents of the kids that disobey the schools laws regarding cell phone use! Teach boundaries and consequences if rules are broken and your kids will follow in line! That will make the whole cell phone-in-school-issu e a lot easier and SAFER for everyone!
Top "Yes" articles on:
Should children have cell phones at school?-
1 of 48
by Petra Sando
Should children have cell phones at school? Yes YES! I believe our kids should have cell phones with them at al...read more
-
2 of 48
by Holle Abee
I'm a teacher at a large high school, and the cell phone debate has been raging for years. Most parants and teens bel...read more
Add your voice
Know something about Should children have cell phones at school?? We want to hear your view. Write now!
Cell phones in school, you're kidding me, right? It is bad enough that teens today have a communication problem with their parents, but let's not encourage the declination of their communication skills any further.
Having been in college and worked on a high school campus, there is nothing more humorous to see than the immediate exit of students from the classroom and the cell phones are out and in use. My wife had to ban them from use in our car because the kids would spend their time texting someone instead of actually talking. Once I caught them texting the person sitting right next to them.
To survive in our world, you have to communicate. I'm not talking about the one word answers or the abbreviated LOLs and CYAs; real communication where thoughts and ideas are expressed completely, where conversations have substance. I watched my older daughter go through her MySpace mail and I counted the conversations with her friends that were one word or one sentence. I asked her why she didn't just call her friends and she looked at me like I was stupid or something. Speak voice to voice? Why would she do that?
This is the world that they are creating for their future. Communication clipped to acronyms and useless words sent across a digital airway. A world where the speaker has complete control of their anonymity. They can be as insincere and dishonest as they choose. Their words can express as little of their true feeling as they want without ever looking the other person in the eyes.
Enough of the soapbox. The tragedy that I have seen with the use of cell phones, other than the above mentioned problems, is that information is too easily passed from one person to another. I have seen students with their cell phones on silent and texting answers back and forth. In classrooms that are becoming more and more over-crowded, this gets passed up frequently. I have seen kids bored to death with their class and have spent the whole time texting with someone else. I have tried to have conversations with students, only to have them text someone else in the middle of our discussion and think nothing of it, voicelessly saying that my conversation isn't nearly as important as the one with the person texting them.
I know that in our world today safety is a huge issue, especially when it comes to our children. I bought a cell phone for my daughter when she went to college for her first semester. She needed it to arrange for rides and for her protection and our peace of mind. I purposely didn't get the phone plan with texting included. I also know that there are plenty of ways to keep someone safe without the use of a cell phone; screaming, running, avoiding situations that invite problems.
Having weighed the options; should cell phones be allowed at school? No. If you want to protect your kids, by all means, take their cell phones away.
Top "No" articles on:
Should children have cell phones at school?Add your voice
Know something about Should children have cell phones at school?? We want to hear your view. Write now!
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
- Education (Other)
- Does competition in schools and colleges lead to higher quality work?
- Should school counselors uphold patient privacy or report students who might become unstable?
- Should public schools offer courses in the Bible?
- Should schools or parents be in control of a child's education?
- Should all school pupils be made to learn at least one foreign language?
- Is there a solution to school violence?
