Home > Sports & Recreation > Training & Equipment
Results so far:
| No | 84% | 889 votes | Total: 1057 votes | |
| Yes | 16% | 168 votes |
No
Created on: October 06, 2007 Last Updated: May 01, 2011
Bodybuilding is a form of body modification, and not an exercise - although done properly, some health benefits do arise. As a form of body modification it involves developing well-defined and bulky muscles. In professional competitions, you are then judged on the aesthetic appeal of these muscles.
There are several reasons body-building would be a poor choice of sport for students to be have to engage in.
>>> Competition Over Appearance <<<
The first is that students (and, indeed, most people) are under intense pressure to look a certain way already. By making it compulsory for everyone to aspire to a six-pack you open up the door to a host of eating disorders, esteem issues and inferiority complexes for people already under academic stress.
>>> Valuing Appearance Over Fitness <<<
Fitness and healthy living is something that should be at the forefront of our educational system. With diet and lifestyle related disease now accounting for a large percentage of deaths in the western world, diet and exercise should be a key component of every school and workplace. Body-building, however, is not about fitness but about appearance, Whilst you can bodybuild in a healthy way, it is also possible to severely compromise your health through extreme dieting techniques, the abuse of supplements, and by forcing your body to work too hard too fast.
Instead, basic fitness classes should be made compulsory - and by giving students a choice between a variety of activities (swimming, dance class, gym sessions etc) it can help each person find a regime that they enjoy and are more likely to stick with later in life.
>>> Health Risks <<<
Bodybuilding carries it with it some risks to the health. For example, a core component of bodybuilding is weight-lifting. Done properly, this is a safe and easy way to build muscle. Lift weights with poor technique, however, and you put enormous stress on your joints and tendons. This can hurt!
In addition, a key part of bodybuilding is diet. Getting the defined look for each muscle involves 'cutting', a diet that aims for extreme fat-loss. Again, with adequate training and knowledge this can be accomplished safely, but without that knowledge you run the risk of restricting important nutrients and depriving your body of what it needs. At best this will impact on academic ability, at worse it can cause heart problems.
Finally, there is the risk of steroids and other drugs. People are competitive, and even professional athletes have been caught 'cheating'. Colleges and schools are already places where drugs are readily available, and it would not take long for someone to see profit in the sales of steroids to anxious competitors. These drugs carry with them enormous side effects and health risks.
In conclusion we can see that bodybuilding is a problematic activity, that should only be undertaken by people who are willing to put in the work. It should not be made compulsory, and certainly should not be considered more beneficial than other forms of exercise.
Learn more about this author, Julie Dancer.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Yes
Created on: March 21, 2010 Last Updated: March 24, 2010
Some claim that certain students just don't succeed at physical fitness. In cases where medical reasons are present, this is true. In most cases, the average nerd is perfectly capable of being physically fit. At my school, the most successful students academically were usually physically active. Some weren't, but I'd say they were more physically fit than the average student. Why? It's simply that students with high degrees of intelligence should recognize that physical fitness is beneficial. It increases things like energy and concentration, and that's important for academic success. Thus, regular physical exercise, including bodybuilding, makes sense for students who want to maximize their GPA.
At my high school, I accepted the label "nerd" with pride. However, I also exercised regularly despite having a genetic condition that makes me prone to overheating. I still gave my best effort, played soccer regularly, and was more physically fit than the average student. I still didn't compete with the hockey players at lifting weights, but I could hold my own in soccer and running. In fact, I was one of the fastest runners. Now many nerds will complain of hand eye coordination issues, but these get better with practice, and they aren't needed for weight lifting.
I started lifting weights for basketball, and I worked out at school and at home. My physical education classes tragically stopped before my last two years of high school, but I enrolled in additionally physical education classes by choice. I worked with weights, ran, and improved my health and confidence. My teacher also used positive reinforcement to help some of my obese friends lose weight. I can't sugarcoat it. They had weight problems. Contrary to what some might thing, my friends benefited and enjoyed improving their health; it was all about having a positive environment.. We didn't insult them, we encouraged them and praised them based on effort and how much they improved.
Bodybuilding is important. I walk my dogs regularly and get a decent amount of cardiovascular exercise. In its own way, lifting weights adds strength, energy, etc. It can't simply be substituted for more cardio. Now people might have some gut reactions against compulsory bodybuilding. However, this may be because women are pressured to look a certain way. And frankly, real women are more attractive than models. Having women develop some muscle and upper body strength can improve their self-image and hopefully put society in the right direction when it comes to this stick-thin nonsense that dominates our culture. A healthy women should have muscle. They don't need to be a body builder, but if your legs are a bit bigger than average, that's because you work out. It's normal to be able to lift relatively heavy things without health. Many people, men and women, are unable to do so.
Another problem is implementing a bodybuilding routine in schools. A lot of the responsibility falls on the teachers. I know some of my teachers allowed unfit students to be taunted. This didn't motivate them and, if anything, it made them avoid exercise altogether because of harassment. Furthermore, many teachers don't organize classes for promoting fitness. If you are playing soccer, the unfit kids will often stand around or walk. They won't get much exercise. If you're going to play soccer and other sports, you need to grade participation and encourage people to work hard. You can even grade other students higher for praising other students and passing the ball. I know this promotes radical values that don't preach letting the weak fall on their face. But in reality, we're all vulnerable at some point, and it's better to have a society that encourages one another. Furthermore, I've seen teachers let students choose not to participate. This is not acceptable when low physical fitness is a national problem.
You don't need to make students look like professional body builders. If a guy works his way up to lifting thirty pound dumbbells, it's not the weight that matters. He might not be comfortable with having too much muscle. Everyone has an aesthetic they like. And frankly, too much muscle adds weight that stresses the heart. More exercise is not "always" better. And women might not want to lift more than a certain amount. It's not the weight that matters. Let people control how much they want to tone their body. However, weight lifting is incredibly beneficial and should be incorporated into the lifestyle of students.
And to all the nerds remembering the tough times they had. I feel for you, but you would've been better off if bodybuilding was in the curriculum. When students play sports, physical contact is allowed. It's often used as a means for bullies to push around nerds. This happened to me. I also got stronger. When the guy who picks on you is suddenly the one on the ground instead of you, he will quickly tell people you are cool to save himself embarrassment. Compulsory bodybuilding would be a huge improvement for the education system.
Learn more about this author, Lucius Trae.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.