Health & Fitness >
Substance Abuse
Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedIs smoking pot benign or a serious health hazard?
Results so far:
| Serious | 53% | 433 votes | Total: 818 votes | |
| Benign | 47% | 385 votes |
Serious
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesFirst, I am only on this side because I believe that excessive chain smoking and/or ingestion of unregulated and adulterated marijuana is the only serious health hazard associated with marijuana use.
Regular use of pure, unadulterated marijuana is no more harmful than drinking reasonable amounts of alcohol. Unadulterated marijuana is far less harmful than some of over the counter and prescription medicines that are in my medicine cabinet right now. Overdoing arthritis medicines, such as NSAIDS and Tylenol can have far more harmful effects to the stomach or liver than marijuana use. When we consider that marijuana can be administered without smoking, the health hazards become minimal.
But, when marijuana is unregulated and is used excessively for recreational mood alteration, there is a grave health concern. When marijuana is laced with Phenacyclidine or Methamphetamine, I consider the results to be catastrophic after even one use. When marijuana is chain-smoked constantly, every day, all day, then of course the resulting lung and respiratory insults will be serious.
Is marijuana a "gateway" drug? Marijuana possession carries far less criminal penalty than the serious addictive and mood altering substances. It is cheaper and easier to obtain. But in the historical time line of the individual who develops serious chemical dependencies, pilfered alcohol, cheap street drugs, and even pilfered prescription drugs are available to take a person much farther on the path to physical self destruction.
So my contribution to the debate, on the side of "serious health hazard", only concerns the unregulated and uncontrolled marijuana that contains dangerous or unknown additives, and is used solely as a mood altering substance by individuals who have emotional disorders or dysfunction that will inevitably lead to excessive use of any mood altering or addictive substances.
I support legalizing marijuana for medical use only.
I emphasize that addictive, immature, and irresponsible individuals would abuse even legalized marijuana, and are more than likely to also abuse alcohol, illegal street drugs, and even prescription medications in order to maintain a detachment from reality, to adjust their mood, or to satisfy their addictions.
If medical marijuana were legalized, then regulation would ensue, and a much safer substance would be made available. Individuals who are prescribed medicinal marijuana receive safe, regulated marijuana. They are issued limited amounts, with scheduled dosages. They may ingest in ways that do not involve excessive smoking. Such users have done well, with much fewer harmful side effects than many prescription medications that provide similar relief from their symptoms.
Learn more about this author, Elizabeth M. Young.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Benign
by Jack Evans
The question of is smoking Marihuana dangerous will largely depend on who you ask, where they get their information, the reliability of the information, and whether or not the individual has actually partaken of the herb. Furthermore to what do we compare the alleged dangerousness of this plant; hashish, heroine, cocaine, methamphetamine, alcohol, tobacco, narcotics or physician prescribed FDA approved medication?
The idea that Marijuana is harmful to the health of an individual is based on studies done in the 1960s and 1970s. In the book "Marijuana Myths, Marijuana Facts", Dr. Lynn Zimmer and John Morgan address this issue:
"In 1972, after reviewing the scientific evidence, the National Commission on Marihuana and Drug Abuse concluded that while marijuana was not entirely safe, its dangers had been grossly overstated. Since then, researchers have conducted thousands of studies of humans, animals, and cell cultures. None reveal any findings dramatically different from those described by the National Commission in 1972. In 1995, based on thirty years of scientific research editors of the British medical journal Lancet concluded that "the smoking of cannabis, even long term, is not harmful to health."
Comparing the harmful effects of marijuana to approved medications prescribed by licensed physicians, the FDA reveals to Medical Marijuanaprocon.org in an FOIA request that the primary suspect of the deaths of individuals using marijuana is 0 compared to 10,008. This includes 196 deaths caused by taking anti emetics (Compazine, Reglan, Marinol, Zofran, Anzemet, Kytril, Tigan), 118 for taking anti-spasmodics (Baclofen, Zanaflex), 1539 deaths for taking anti-psychotics (Haldol, Lithium, Neurontin), and 8101 deaths for taking medications in the treatment of ADD, depression, narcolepsy, erectile dysfunction and pain (Ritalin, Wellbutrin, Adderall, Viagra, Vioxx). (See: http://www.medicalma rijuanaprocon.org/po p/deathreports.htm)
D oes Marijuana impare driving ability? No. "No increased risk for road trauma was found for drivers exposed to cannabis." ("Psychoactive Substance Use and the Risk of Motor Vehicle Accidents," by K.L.L. Movig et al. (Vol. 36, No. 4, pp. 631-636, July 2004)
Can Marijuana cause death? No. "No acute lethal overdoses of cannabis are known, in contrast to several of its illegal (for example, cocaine) and legal (for example, alcohol, aspirin, acetaminophen) counterparts." (The British Medical Journal by Stephen Sidney M.D. Vol. 327, pp. 635-635)
Does Marijuana cause lung cancer? No. "We found absolutely no suggestion of a dose response [i.e. marijuana smoking leads directly to lung cancer].The data on tobacco use... revealed a very potent effect and clear dose-response relationship - a 21-fold greater risk of developing lung cancer if you smoke more than two packs a day. So, in summary, we failed to observe a positive association of marijuana use and other potential co-founders." (Donald P. Tashkin, M.D., reported at the June 2005 meeting of the International Cannabinoid Research Society on his as-yet unpublished study of 1,209 Los Angeles residents aged 59 or younger with cancer:)
Does marijuana damage the brain? No. In the aforementioned book book Marijuana Myths, Marijuana Facts Dr. Zimmer states that "None of the medical tests currently used to detect brain damage in humans have found harm from marijuana, even from long-term high-dose use....The claim that marijuana destroys brain cells is based on a speculative report dating back a quarter of a century that has never been supported by any scientific study."
The fact of the matter is:
1. Medical marijuana decreases nausea and vomiting of patients undergoing chemotherapy, (New England Journal of Med. 1975 Oct 16;293(16):795-797).
2. Reduce or eliminate seizures (Lutz B; Biochem Pharmacol. 2004 Nov 1; 68(9):1691-8).
3. Reduce inner ocular pressure of glaucoma patients (Hepler RS, Frank IM.; J. Amer. Med. Assn. 1971; 217: 1392).
4. Decreases nausea and increases appetite in late stage HIV/AIDS patients (Braitstein, Paulaab, Kendall et al,; AIDS. 2001 March 9; 15(4): 532-533).
5. Treats migraines (Russo EB.; Neuor Endocrinol Lett. 2004 Feb-Apr; 25(1-2):31-9).
6. Symptoms of MS (Baker D, Pryce G, Croxford JL, et al; FASEB Journal. 2001; 15: 300-302).
7. Chronic pain (Milstein SL, MacCannell K, Karr G, Clark S.; Int Pharmacopsychiatry. 1975; 10(3):177-82), and pain and inflammation of arthritis (DePetrocellis L, Melck D, Bisogns T, Di Marzo V.; Chem Phys Lipids. 2000 Nov; 108(1-2):191-209
Fina lly, if Marijuana is in fact harmful, then why is it that these National and International Health Organizations support its use for medical purposes? This list does not include State and Local Organizations, AIDS Organizations, Health Organizations or National and International Organizations.
AIDS Action Council
AIDS Treatment News
American Academy of Family Physicians
American Medical Student Association
American Nurses Association
American Preventive Medical Association
American Public Health Association
American Society of Addiction Medicine
Arthritis Research Campaign (United Kingdom)
Australian Medical Association (New South Wales) Limited
Australian National Task Force on Cannabis
Belgian Ministry of Health
British House of Lords Select Committee on Science and Technology
British House of Lords Select Committee On Science and Technology (Second Report)
British Medical Association
Canadian AIDS Society
Canadian Special Senate Committee on Illegal Drugs
Dr. Dean Edell (surgeon and nationally syndicated radio host)
French Ministry of Health
Health Canada
Kaiser Permanente
Lymphoma Foundation of America
The Montel Williams MS Foundation
Multiple Sclerosis Society (Canada)
The Multiple Sclerosis Society (United Kingdom)
National Academy of Sciences Institute Of Medicine (IOM)
National Association for Public Health Policy
National Nurses Society on Addictions
Netherland s Ministry of Health
New England Journal of Medicine
New South Wales (Australia) Parliamentary Working Party on the Use of Cannabis for Medical Purposes
Learn more about this author, Jack Evans.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
