Health & Fitness >
Contraception
Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedIs the new contraceptive pill that stops menstruation healthy for women?
Results so far:
| No | 79% | 312 votes | Total: 395 votes | |
| Yes | 21% | 83 votes |
No
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesWhy does the little black box of science continually think they can improve upon what has been a normal, human, female bodily function for eons? It is doubtful for any health benefits for women. More likely it is because it removes one bodily function that the male gender has found objectionable for a variety of reasons. Women have been classified as unclean in nearly every religion in the world while on their monthly cycle. Why? Possibly because men find the flow of blood from a woman's body distasteful and a barrier to their enjoyment of intercourse?
Whatever the reasons, women have been vilified for this normal body function for all too long. A great book to read is 'The Red Tent'...won't answer your questions, but will let you know how long this male created myth has been in existence. It is also a great account of women's ability to support each other even in difficult times.
If a woman chooses to cease her periods for her own reasons and/or benefit then as long as she understands the inherent risks involved, that is her right. But please be sure you know what those risks are. And be aware that if you stop a natural cycle there is no guarantee that you will be able to return to the normal and natural rhythm when you decide you want a child. Also, if you stop this flow there is an increased chance that you may end up with too much iron in your system; either from the meats you eat, or the iron fortified vitamins many women take because of their monthly cycles. These are the things that will likely be overlooked as you are given the spiel on how wonderful it will be for you not to have a monthly period.
Don't jump on this bandwagon too soon. All too often what science says is good practice today, becomes the medical horrors of tomorrow. Look up the thalidomide babies of the 60s. This was a drug that doctors freely gave to pregnant women, assuring them it was absolutely safe, and would help them to get better sleep while pregnant. What happened was thousands of babies born horrifically deformed. Science at its best. More recently the Fen-Phen debacle, with resulting permanent heart/lung damage for many who simply wanted to lose a few extra pounds.
Are monthly periods a pain in the ass at times? Yes. Is stopping them worth risking my future childbearing options or general health? NO! I, for one, choose not to mess with the normal functioning of my body. When, or if, it becomes broken is when I will intervene...hopefull y, in a more natural and less dangerous way.
Learn more about this author, Mb Rose.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Yes
First, let me say that I am not a physician, and all of my opinions are simply based upon personal experience.
I have been taking birth control pills on and off since I was 17 years old. I went through a time in college when I had a reaction to several different kinds of pills, all of which caused me to have severe "bladder infections". Eventually I found a doctor who was able to figure out the exact reason why I was having so much trouble and she put me on a very "low dose" birth control pill.
About a year ago, I went in for my regular "Pap Smear" and "Well Woman Exam", and my doctor suggested that I try the new "Seasonal" birth control pill which would only cause me to have my period every four months. I was a bit skeptical at first, but my doctor explained the way that the pill worked and how it had been widely tested and used already and the side effects where no more prevalent than in regular birth control pills. Numerous studies have been done over the passed 10 to 15 years, and there have been no serious issues reported (at least nothing more serious than with ordinary birth control pills).
I have now been on "Seasonal" for over a year and I love it. I only have to worry about having my period once very four months, and when I do have my period, it is usually very light in comparison to what it used to be. I haven't experienced any of the weight gain, bloating, mood swings...nothing like what I dealt with in the past. I would suggest this type of birth control pill to anyone who doesn't want to have to worry about having their period every month...and what woman wouldn't want that!?
Learn more about this author, Sarah Williams.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
