Search Helium

Home > Society & Lifestyle > Ethnicity & Gender > Gender Issues

Does biology or society have a stronger influence on the development of our gender identity?

Results so far:

Biology
35% 288 votes Total: 831 votes
Society
65% 543 votes

Biology

by Jasmine Starr

Created on: March 08, 2009

Biology is entirely responsible for gender identity. This is being supported more and more by scientific evidence. With regard to biology, there is increasing evidence that hormonal effects on fetal development play a significant role in development of gender identity.




Melissa Hines postulated three models of action of hormonal influences on gender in 2002:




"The Classic Model of hormonal influences states that presence of testicular hormones (testosterone) during early fetal life causes a masculine development of rodents, while absence of testicular hormones causes a feminine development.




The Gradient Model describes a more gradual effect of hormonal influences on behavior. Normal variations in hormones cause movement along a male and female gradient within each sex. Therein we assume that a greater amount of hormones administered in animal tests, creates a more dramatic change in behavior.




The Model of Active Feminization Theory postulates that ovarian hormones are, opposed to the previous mentioned models, needed to induce, in some degree, the female sexual differentiation. It is thought that ovarian hormones cause a lesser, but present effect of mild virilization to some brain areas."1




Biology is also seemingly implied in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR) as gender identity disorder "..represents a profound disturbance of the individual's sense of identity with regard to maleness or femaleness."2 (emphasis added)




My thesis is also supported by personal experience. I am a transsexual, and I know my identity is inherent. I was born and raised in the rural South in the 1970's. Being an effeminate boy was unheard of in that culture. I tried very hard to conform, but I was still subjected to ridicule and bullying. While I attempted to fit in by adjusting my outward gender expression, my internal and inherent gender identity was ultimately betraying me.




Based on some of the articles written supporting societies' role in forming gender identity, I think there is some confusion between gender identity and gender expression. The two are distinct, yet easily confused.




Gender identity is inherent and internalized. It is impossible to determine an individual's gender identity by their appearance. If the individual has a gender identity that is incongruent with their physiological sex, they may not have come to terms with that and might still be presenting themselves as the gender that does match their physiological sex. I did that for thirty-six years. Gender identity is entirely about how the individual personally (and honestly) identifies or classifies themselves.




Gender expression, however, is how one presents gender externally. Dress, mannerisms and speech are key indicators. Much of what is acceptable for gender expression is a societal construct. There are countless unwritten rules regarding what is acceptable for a masculine or feminine gender expression. In the modern western world, we live in a society that largely recognizes only two genders. For those interested in getting a more comprehensive and eye-opening view of gender expression, roles, and identity, I recommend the book "Gender Outlaw" by Kate Bornstein3.




Based on the research, the evidence, and my own personal experience gender identity is a biological phenomena. Gender expression, by contrast, is largely a societal construct and the means by which we express (or suppress) our inherent gender identity.








1) Hines M, "Sexual Differentiation of Human Brain and Behavior". Hormones, Brain and Behavior. Vol. 4. 2002: Elsevier Science (USA). Pp. 425-461.




2) American Psychiatric Association, "Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition Text Revision". Jaypee 2000. p. 580




3) Bornstein K, "Gender Outlaw on Men Women, and the Rest of Us" Routledge 1994

Learn more about this author, Jasmine Starr.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Society

by Angie Haggstrom

Created on: August 06, 2007

Society, rather than biology, is the main determining factor in defining one's gender identity. Biological make up and physical traits are unique to each individual. Society tells us that if we possess certain physical components, then we need to behave according to the rules that it has determined as normal. Females, males, and those caught in between are told what to say, how to behave, and what thoughts and dreams are appropriate.

Females are groomed from birth to suit society's standards of behavior. Girls play house, dolls, wear pink, and follow in the footsteps of their female role models. If a girl demonstrates boy-like behaviors, she is labeled as "tom boy" and pressured to change by the world around her.

Male children are reared to be strong and even unemotional. Boys are encouraged to play with trucks, building blocks, and develop interest in sports. They are taught to follow male role models by choosing a lifestyle that society will deem not only as acceptable, but is seen as a successful male role. "Be a man" or "toughen up" are common phrases used by their peers. Males who do not follow the rules are given labels and pressure is exerted on them to change.

Trans gender individuals and homosexuals may be physically different, but it is their behavior patterns that set them apart. Many trans gender people have had their identity chosen for them at birth. As they grow and develop, they choose their likes and dislikes. Society then takes this information and decides whether that person is following the correct path.

Homosexuals are those who are the mental and emotional opposite of their physical make up. Society sees these people doing the reverse of what they should. For example, a woman who portrays male qualities is still considered female.

Society's gender paradigm limits educational and career choices. Females are encouraged to work in industries such as food, childcare, and nursing. Jobs in these areas focus on what society sees as skills that women should excel at.

For women who choose to follow an educational or career path outside of what society finds acceptable, conflict and inequality are common. Girls who desire to enter the field of construction, for example, are expected to work longer hours, out perform their male counterparts, and be willing to do the dirty jobs. They collect less pay than men and have to work twice as hard to climb the ladder of success. The same is true for men who chose positions and education thought of as feminine.

The roles of men and women in relationships are also structured by society. Women are expected to care for the home and children. The main objectives for men are to be protective and provide an income to adequately support the household. Conflict often arises between a man and a woman when they feel that their partner does not satisfactorily fit into their gender identity.

When women decide to take employment outside of the home, they often need to convince their significant other that they can fill both roles effectively. Men also view this as an infringement on their household role as provider. Men who want to look after the home and children appear to their community as being lazy and useless. Men and women judge their success as a husbands, wives, mothers and fathers on how successfully they fit into society's gender identities.

Society's methods of influence are wide spread. Media, business, peers, adults, and even the education system dictate society's ideas of acceptable conduct for the genders. Feminism and macho-ism only seem to heighten the differences between the sexes. Competition is strongly encouraged. On items such as mailing addresses, men are listed first.

Although there are biological differences, it is society that defines our gender role. Biology indicates whether we are male or female, but society tells each of the sexes which identity they will have.

Learn more about this author, Angie Haggstrom.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA