Home > Politics, News & Issues > Sports News & Opinion > Sports Archives
Results so far:
| No | 54% | 91 votes | Total: 167 votes | |
| Yes | 46% | 76 votes |
No
Created on: August 31, 2007 Last Updated: October 31, 2008
As Lloyd Grossman once said on a daytime television quiz show, "Let's look at the evidence".
And, when it comes to Tottenham Hotspur's aspirations of making the top four this year, the bad news for their fans is that the evidence is damning.
In the F.A. Cup quarter finals last year, they dominated a Chelsea who were lacking the resiliance and sheer bloody mindliness that characterised their successive championship victories under Jose Mourinho.
But quite frankly, after being 3-1 up at half time, they let the then champions of England off the hook, the defence sat back deeper and deeper, and ended up drawing the game 3-3.
That proved to be as close as they got; Tottenham lost the replay at home 2-1.
There was a similar tale of woe in the League Cup competition when they played Arsenal in the semi finals.
The Gunners, fielding a strong but, by all accounts, reserve side, were in turmoil in the first half, and were lucky to be just 2-0 behind at half time.
But yet again Tottenham, fielding as many first team players available to them as possible, threw way the initiative, and two Julio Baptista goals in the second half gave Arsenal vital away goals which were the platform for them to make the final.
This demonstrates the problems we have with Spurs when compared to the top teams in England.
Every season, each of the so-called "big four" - Manchester United, Chelsea, Liverpool and Arsenal - aren't so much thinking about securing a top four finish in the league, but ultimately think only about winning the league championship, with a top four finish taking care of itself. They are winning machines, who are professional ruthless in their approach towards their goals.
Contrast that with the attitude of Tottenham Hotspur.
A club who call themselves "big", but haven't won the league championship since the 1960s, whose last F.A. Cup triumph came in 1991 - before the Premiership era - and who, up until 2006, hadn't qualified for Europe via the league for twenty years (their one round, 1999 foray into UEFA Cup coming through winning the league cup).
Twice last season they were in winning positions in major cup competitions, which represented their best chance of silverware, against top four clubs, and twice they blew their opportunities.
Players don't deliberately avoid winning, but as a team, Tottenham were scared of winning. Teams that succeed in any major league in the World relish the opportunity of winning; Spurs didn't. Had any of the "Big Four" been in their shoes, they would've taken the opposition to the cleaners.
Then you only have to listen to the men at the top at Spurs to realise why they won't make the top four.
The chairman's ridiculous statement over the position of manager Martin Jol, taking away all the authority of the Dutchman, has not only made Spurs a laughing stock, but has only served to expose their limitations as a major force in the game.
Note how Mr. Levy asks for the minimum of a top four place; not the league championship. Quite simply, most clubs don't care about winning trophies, only increasing their bank balance, which comes as a result of a Champions League place.
Whereas the top players and teams, like Steven Gerrard and Liverpool, whilst concerned about money, as is true in all cases in the modern game, realise that silverware and medals give greater personal satisfaction and a true signal of achievement during a player's career.
Oh, and then there is the footballing side.
Tottenham have a potentially very good squad on paper, capable of upsetting the apple cart of the "big four", their strike force in particular amongst the very best in the Premier League.
But they are a side lacking in experience, both in terms of age and in the art of winning, and with a lack of experience inevitably comes mistakes at key moments in games from the younger players. At present, the players are good enough only to ocassionly trouble the top four, not stay there.
Martin Jol's management has also come into question with the whole Juande Ramos scenario, but when you consider that David Moyes and Everton have finished fourth within the past three years with a squad of local players and signings from the second division, and the performances of Blackburn and Bolton in breaking into the top six with limited resources under Mark Hughes and Sam Allardyce respectively, there are question marks as to whether or not Jol can take Spurs the extra yard.
Given that Spurs have actively been seeking a replacement, they must have their doubts.
A change of attitude from just trying to compete with the top four into a winning, ruthless one, could result in Tottenham achieving a top four finish. Until they do that, they will continue to live in the shadows of the other big clubs.
Learn more about this author, Sam Todd.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Yes
Created on: August 03, 2007 Last Updated: October 31, 2008
Having just watched the current Tottenham Hotspurs side in action for their penultimate pre-season game at Leyton Orient, I was notably surprised with an expectant Spurs side that again attempts to claim that elusive fourth spot and lucrative draw of Champions League football. A comfortable 4-2 victory at Brisbane Road showcased the array of attacking talent at Martin Jol's disposal this season but also emphasized those areas which could potentially harness their bid to break into the top four.
Their pre-season held many positives, in particular the goal scoring form of Darren Bent. The new 16.5 million acquisition from Charlton seems to have adapted to life at White Hart Lane greatly and crucially completes a strong four-pronged attack line which is essential for the North London club to be challenging for a top four position.
Much has been written about Arsenal's untenable position, intensified by the sale of their top asset Thierry Henry as Tottenham's route into the elite. But with a returning Robin Van Persie, a fully fit William Gallas to partner Kolo Toure, and a array of prodigious young talent who now have a Premiership seasons experience under their belt, they can not be discounted so easily to give up their position without a fight.
Tottenham are not the only team in the shake-up to break the stranglehold that the current top four clubs have over the remaining clubs. Everton who finished two points behind Tottenham last season may not have spent lavishly over the summer but have a settled squad, who show tremendous fight for each other, and possess enough quality in midfield and upfront to mount a challenge. Portsmouth who were amongst those last season have bought well in midfielder Sully Muntari and strengthened at the back as well as up front with the signings of John Utaka and Dave Nugent. Among the big spenders, West Ham have bought well in Scott Parker, Craig Bellamy, and Bordeaux's Julien Faubert amongst others, and should not be discounted for being among the front-runners. Sam Allardyce at Newcastle has revamped a much-needed Newcastle squad and with a returning Michael Owen and a more shored up defense that they can also be considered as challengers. Aston Villa is a team to look out for this season in the shake up for fourth spot. Martin O Neill is building a team that possesses an impressive spine of young English talent, who will be fearless as they look to be regarded as genuine contenders.
A top four team is built on a solid back line, Manchester United showed that their ever-present back four provided the basis for their title winning side, as did a mean Chelsea defence. Tottenham have a strong partnership in the centre of defence in England internationals Michael Dawson and Ledley King, while Pascal Chimbonda has established the right back spot and new signing Gareth Bale certain to make the left back position his own. Problems will begin to surface with injuries to these key players; in the centre back roles Ricardo Rocha failed to impress last season, while new signing Younes Kaboul will need time to embed into the team. The question is whether this squad will be strong enough in quality to cover for what is an impressive first-choice back four.
Their depth of midfield talent will ensure that Spurs are top of the chasing pack comprising of disciplined tough tackling midfielders in Zokora and Jenas, and abundant creativity courtesy of Tom Huddlestone and Aaron Lennon amongst others. In addition to this they have what can be considered a precocious talent in Adel Taarbat. Signed on a permanent deal after a productive loan spell from Lens, Taarbat is being talked about as the Spurs Zidane'. With a host of tricks and the enthusiasm to run at defences with great pace, the dynamic midfielder could become a key player for Spurs over the upcoming season.
The mental strength of both the playing staff and the manager will be a crucial aspect in a successful season for Spurs. The team will have to believe they warrant a place among the elite clubs and that can be addressed with improving what has been over previous seasons, a poor head to head record against the top four. Martin Jol himself will surely have to familiarize with the host of mind games, which will emanate through the season to test his resolve and instill a belief in his squad. Ferguson, Mourinho, Benitez, and Wenger have had plenty of experience dealing with the crossfire of words through the press and it will have to be something that Jol can learn to use to his advantage, and know when not to be drawn into.
Having come so close in recent seasons with consecutive fifth place finishes, optimism and experience can be taken from both campaigns. Spurs fans will have every reason to look forward to the forthcoming Premiership campaign; Martin Jol has assembled a fine squad of players and perhaps with a few additions to come possesses a team most certainly capable of launching an assault on that all important top four berth. With their North London rivals experiencing a transitional period, Spurs fans will surely see this as their best opportunity in recent years for a youthful, but rapidly maturing, talented squad to achieve that much coveted place amongst the elite of Premiership football.
Learn more about this author, Michael Sawh.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.