My Helium | Join | Log in Where Knowledge Rules

Politics, News & Issues:

International Politics

Debate_icon

RSS RSS Feed

Get a Widget for this title

Is the war in Iraq bad for the US economy?

Results so far:

No
23% 85 votes Total: 369 votes
Yes
77% 284 votes
No

If you're familiar with the "Orphan Annie" comic strip, movie and Broadway show, you know about the Daddy Warbucks character. Have you ever thought of the meaning of his name? The big, bluff industrialist with a heart of gold for the little lost girl was created by cartoonist Harold Grey in the 1920s, the years following World War I.

During that war, as in every one before and since, there were clever businessmen who made tons of money ... war bucks ... from supplying goods and services to their governments. Thus was created Daddy Warbucks, whose enormous fortune came from providing the goods and services that equipped the doughboys who went off France to fight "the war to end all wars".

You may believe the current war is actually bad for the U.S. economy. It certainly is for the average citizen who is desperately trying to survive financially amid rampant inflation at the gas pump, grocery store and real estate market. It is terribly bad for the parents who must send their children into combat, and military families who may lose their father or mother as the killing continues.

However, if you can cynically consider the opportunities out there to make lots of bucks, it has to be a bonanza for those who profit from the war. The current controversy about the Blackwater private guard organization isn't just based on their opportunism to profit from the war, which is highly suspect, but primarily on their alleged indiscriminate killing of Iraqi civilians.

However, if you look into the statistics, they will serve as a typical example of making war bucks. The average Blackwater employee, the guy who carries the gun and protects VIPs and convoys, earns between $150,000 and $250,000 a year. A similar job in the US, although nowhere nearly as dangerous, pays from $35,000 to $50,000.

Of course, all Blackwater expenses, as inflated as they are, pale before the profits being made by manufacturers of weapons, vehicles, uniforms, aircraft, ships and the thousands of other expensive items and services needed to pursue the war. Most people involved in the transactions adhere to regular business practices, but examples of grossly excessive charges, under-the-table payoffs, bribery of foreign governments and outright thievery are as rampant in this war as they've been in every conflict and defense build-up since the 1776 US revolution.

"War is good for business" is quoted every day in 2007 A.D. in boardrooms and stock exchanges throughout the U.S. You can be sure the phrase was certainly said first by armorers and spearmakers way back in 2007 B.C. Sparta.

Learn more about this author, Ted Sherman.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Yes

War is, by its very nature, bad for the economy. It produces nothing and destroys much. By definition, this is anti-economic behavior. Certainly there are opportunities to rebuild when war is over, but these can never justify to losses and costs.

A small segment of the population has long been able to exploit war for short-term profits. Thomas Paine complained in Rights of Man that the governments of Europe had frequently generated war to justify taxes. President Eisenhower in his farewell address warned of the dangers of the Military-Industrial Complex. Today, Dick Cheney's firm, Halliburton, and the oil giants seem to be profiting at the loss of US service people and the citizens of Iraq.

Aggressive war is a violation of treaties promoted by the US at the end of WWII, Nuremberg, Geneva, and the UN Charter. When we hold the criminals accountable for this misbehavior, it will be time for a Truth & Reconciliation Commission on Complicity in War Profiteering. If we dig deep enough, each of us who buys the oil they fight over must take some responsibility.

Imagi ne all the good we could accomplish if the US weren't spending more money than any government in history on military, more than twice all our potential enemies combined. Besides solving more of our own problems, we could generate goodness all over the planet, following Lincoln's advise on the elimination of enemies by converting them to friends.

Learn more about this author, Vernon Huffman.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA