Search Helium

Home > Society & Lifestyle > Lifestyles & Subcultures > Lifestyles

Is it better to live in the city or the country?

Results so far:

Country
61% 2394 votes Total: 3924 votes
City
39% 1530 votes

Country

by Ann Major

Created on: January 22, 2008   Last Updated: July 25, 2011

Having a preference for city or country living often depends on the age group. At a certain time in one's life, there is a yearning to replace the faster-paced city life with quieter surroundings of the country. For someone who has yo-yoed back and forth between country, city, small town, bigger city, back to the country again, rural living is definitely the way to go.

This writer was born in a small village with one dirt road which led to an enclave of homes with no running water and no toilets. What was available was comparable to an outhouse in the old days in America. Eventually relocating to a congested city such as Hong Kong was a complete turnaround.

Living in Hong Kong was like being in a citified cage, where no youngster could venture past his apartment building without the presence of an adult. Children were walked to and from school by extended family members.  In a city of that caliber, the attitude is to trust no one. So other than going to school, pastimes often consisted of looking out of the apartment window, watching moving throngs of people being moved along like a human wave.

Sundays were rest days for every working person and a day for doing shopping. So on Sundays, citizens emerged from safety of their crowded rooms/apartments to the streets below; shoving and being shoved, borne along the sidewalk, a wave of shackled people.  City living was no fun.

Small-town living on the East Coast was definitely better than Hong Kong as summers days were spent rummaging around garbage piles, looking for bits and pieces to create masterpiece "go-carts"; walking on railroad tracks to blueberry fields; stealing apples from farmers' yards; and going to adult movies; attending wrestling matches. These activities would not have been possible in a city setting, and because of the era and place, there was more safety within a small-town, rural-like setting.

When adulthood necessitated living in suburbia, privacy was certainly not a luxury which could be afforded. The suburbs do give an individual the chance to be anonymous. If one does not want to know one's neighbors, then city-living or suburbia is the place to be. Socializing with neighbors in the suburbs can sometimes incur unpleasant consequences; when you no longer get along with your neighbors, and houses are in close proximity, where do you go?  

Even though this writer's son considers the country to be, oh so "bo-oring!", the friendliness of country people cannot be denied. Everyone waves to everyone else in the country, whether a person knows them or not. If the person does not wave back, it is assumed they must be from the city, or destined to become one's mortal enemy. In the suburb, a person may wave to a new neighbor; he or she might stare as if one was the village idiot. In the country, if neighbors do not know the newcomer,  they will certainly make up colorful stories about them until they do.

On the other hand, country people are well-meaning when they say " We should have you over for supper sometime' knowing fully well that they have no intentions of doing so.  That it is just a way of saying hello in the country.  In the city, when a person says "Drop in sometime" he or she usually means:" Please don't call me, I'll call you, and don't hold your breath."

In the country, there is an unspoken pecking order which goes far back to one being blue-blooded and having settled in the country when it was still largely unpopulated. On the East Coast, if a person was not born and bred in that area; worst still, chose to go off in search of a job in a city, they are no longer considered local, or a person of note. In fact one is an outsider and forever remains an outsider, as country people are less nomadic than city folk, have roots and stay put.

There is one common element that has to do with both city and country-living. One cannot choose one's neighbors. Obsessive-compulsive neighbors living in suburbia/city are also doubly obsessive with the borderline of their properties. In suburbia, neighbors never mow an extra inch of grass which separates the two houses, since it does not belong to their side. It almost seems like they got a measuring tape out and exacted the borderline. It is often wondered whether a neighbor had a surveyor's blueprint in his/her head.

People in a suburb/city tend to be selfish and often inconsiderate. In this writer's experience, wintertime sports from one's neighbor often consisted of hockey pucks being pummeled against the fence, flying baseballs into the yard, tennis balls, soccer and footballs have all allowed this writer's husband to start a sports kiosk.

In retirement, having moved back to the country, this writer has learned that country people love to put one over city folks. City folks know very little about keeping a country homestead. In the city, everything is done for you. In the country, you have to look for service people, and they don't come cheap, even if they are not the best in their profession.

There are no set prices for any kind of service. If they think you have money, the price goes up. A written contract does not exist. Everything is word-of-mouth, most of the time without a handshake; forget about their coming back to fix any problems once the job is done and cash is in their hands. You may never see them again.

In the city there is more of everything. More jobs, more food, more transportation, availability of services. Cities harbor better doctors, medical care and cheaper consumer goods because there is competition. In the country, if you don't like the prices, too bad. What you see is what you get. If you like peanut butter and there are only three bottles left on the shelves, buy all three because the next time, the shelves may be bare. As with country hospitals, a new one has been built, but with lesser services. The negative of rural-living is not every professional, such as a doctor want to practice in the country.

In the country, everyone is versatile and one must learn to be self-sufficient. The fire chief may be an electrician and whose job is sometimes cut short when he is called away to a fire emergency. A country dweller may pay more for house insurance because the nearest fire hydrant is nowhere to be seen or found.

Then there are the small inconveniences of country living, like potholes on the road that never get filled: a road which does not get plowed in winter until two days later; or garbage that is collected on a bi-monthly basis. If one leaves the garbage out too early, the crows will peck away at it and have a field day. As for the mail, one needs to walk a half mile to get it, but it's a small inconvenience for the positives of rural living.

Country living is food for the soul and quiet and solitude are great for the soul. Having the opportunity to wake up to beautiful sunrises; not having to shower every day, hanging clothes on a clothesline are what define country life. Walking around in rubber duckies is a fashion state in the country as roads tend to be wet and muddy whenever it rains.

In cottage country where this writer lives, the population triples during the summer and trickles to a few hundred in the fall, becoming once again a sleepy little community.  It is so quiet, peace, tranquility, and being at one with nature that draws many people to the country.

Learn more about this author, Ann Major.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

City

by Ella Ivey

Created on: November 07, 2007   Last Updated: November 26, 2011

I'm a city girl through and through, so undoubtedly I just had to choose the city side.

I live in a town just in the outskirts of London so as you can imagine I'm always in and out of the magical, big city. Yes, so it has its down points; the fact that there's always a wave of pollution hitting you as soon as you get out of your car or the train. The fact that people are so busy that they brush past you, hammering your shoulder hard and not even turning back to apologize. And also the fact that if you don't hold o to your handbag properly, it will get knocked off/stolen and never be found again.

But... when you look at the bigger picture there is no place I would rather be in. The excitement thrills me of being somewhere where everyday is a new adventure- where everyday you encounter people you have never met before who suddenly become life-long friends.

I know a few people in Notting Hill, who despite having gone to the best school in England and living in the most fantastic houses, they certainly break the stereotype as the 'rich kids'. They are fun-loving, wonderful, kind, crazy, loud and I know that if I were to ever have a problem they would certainly be there for me.
I also know quite a few people in Chiswick having lived there for 3 months and despite being fun-loving, wonderful and kind, they are also intensely quiet, smart and absolutely perfect for parading through museums or theaters.

That's something I love about city life- you encounter so many different people but they're all into different things and go to different places. I just can't imagine having that sort of life in the country.

Perhaps I'm writing unfairly considering that the most I have spent in the countryside was the total of 6 days where the whole class was made to go by the Biology teachers as part of a field trip. It was horrible (to me anyway). There were no shops for miles and as soon as I emerged my head out of the window, the only thing I could see were soggy, green fields and the smell of cow dung which permeated the air and the only thing I liked about it was that I could wear my brand new black with pink spots wellies (which a week later were a main display at the Bentalls centre in Kingston). Not only that but the only memory I have of the trip was walking for what seemed like miles and miles just to get to the sea side.
I guess it's just not my kind of living. I like hailing a cab whenever I can.

I am a complete Starbucks girl; gathering in this domineering and globalized coffee place with my friends chatting about ... well, everything. After a fantastic dose of latte we would leave Starbucks in the search for a handbag or a pair of shoes at the local boutiques. Ok, so my sort of life sounds slightly superficial... I certainly wasn't expecting that. Maybe I should erase the above.

I have now lived in Guildford for about a year due to starting University and even though it is not as diverse as London and certainly doesn't contain the same hustle as the capital, but nevertheless it is a city; a city I am very fond of. However, despite Guildford being all cobbled streets, marketplaces and fantastic shops, it has hidden treasures of a wonderful past history, a relaxing river and great countryside around it. Great countryside? Never thought I'd be saying that.
What has become more apparent about living in Guildford is that even though I love the excitement of a city life, sometimes it is very necessary to escape... to the countryside. But only for a little bit and certainly in great moderation.

Now, what do I love about living in the city?
The shops of course.
The diversity of cultures.
The fact that you can walk without wellies on.
The wonderful, different people you meet.
Restaurants. I do love eating out.
Evenings out at local bars listening to unsigned artists.
Museums.
Meeting people who are for sure going to be a great success one day.
Learning new things everyday.
Creating new events such as fashion shows for charity.

I cannot tell you enough how wonderful it is to be in the city. To have everything right outside your house, and I guess the most important thing is being able to escape somewhere more peaceful if you ever wanted to. Escape is sometimes a blessing.

Learn more about this author, Ella Ivey.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA