Home > Parenting & Pregnancy > Babies > Feeding & Breastfeeding
Results so far:
| Schedules | 33% | 316 votes | Total: 948 votes | |
| On demand | 67% | 632 votes |
Schedules
Created on: July 25, 2007
Like many things in life, feeding your baby takes common sense.
There are many people who advocate feeding on a strict schedule. To them, the clock makes the decision, and they wait until the appointed time, even if their baby shows hunger signs before then.
On the other side are the demand feed crowd. To them, a baby should be fed each and every time they are hungry, whether it has been three hours or 30 minutes since the last feeding.
I believe that feeding a baby is best done with a combination of these methods. A schedule should be made to allow the baby to regulate a hunger pattern, but a baby's hunger cues should not be ignored, even if they don't follow a schedule.
For example, a newborn baby needs to be fed every two and a half hours or so, if breastfed, and every four hours or so if bottle fed. This is a good goal to work with. A newborn should not go longer than the two and a half hours between meals, lest the mother's milk supply get too low.
However, newborns are very sleepy. Therefore, it is sometimes difficult to get a newborn infant to eat a full meal without falling asleep. What often happens is that the baby will nurse for a few minutes and then fall asleep. He will sleep for an hour or less, and then wake up hungry again. This happens on and off all day, and the mother ends up nursing her baby every hour on the hour.
This was the case with my firstborn. As a new mother, I was told to feed on demand. I thought that meant every time the baby cried, I had to feed him. This is the main problem with the "demand feed" idea. Inexperienced mothers have a hard time determining if the baby is really hungry or if he is crying for some other reason. I ended up with very little sleep, and both me and my son were unhappy.
Finally, I read a book about this subject, and there was some advice that I followed that literally changed my life. The book, "On Becoming Babywise" by Gary Ezzo, suggests that the mother try to keep the baby awake long enough to take a full feeding, and then she should keep her baby awake for a short while after eating. When the child is put to bed, he should be awake.
This system does several things. First, it allows the baby to get a full feeding during the mealtime, instead of having small "snacks" all day. This is good for baby and mother. The baby feels satisfied for longer periods, and the mother's milk comes in better when her breasts are emptied during a feeding.
Second, it allows the baby to regulate his sleep and hunger. Although babies do know, to some degree, when they are hungry, snacking all day confuses a baby's system. So do taking small naps all day as opposed to longer, more restful naps.
And third, it teaches a baby how to fall asleep on his own. Babies who are nursed to sleep have a hard time learning how to fall asleep without a "prop," as the book calls it.
Once I starting using this method, I was amazed at the difference. At first it was hard to keep my son awake for the full half-hour feeding time, but it was worth the effort. Within two weeks, my son was eating on a two and a half hour feeding schedule and taking good naps. By just over two months of age, he was sleeping seven hours at night, and by three months old, he was sleeping ten to twelve hours a night.
I was happier, because I could actually get some sleep, and my son was happier because he was well-rested and well-fed.
The biggest caution I have with this, though, is to make sure you are not ignoring your baby's hunger cues. There were some times, such as during a growth spurt, that my son would be hungry a little bit sooner than the two and a half hours. I would feed him when he was hungry and adjust his schedule. Usually, after a few days, he would get back on his normal schedule. Just make sure that you don't feed your baby just because he is crying. Learn to read your baby. Some babies cry when they are over stimulated or held too much. With time, you will be able to recognize your baby's cues and can act accordingly.
It is possible to have a schedule and to feed your baby when he is hungry. Having a schedule helps to get the baby on a healthy feeding routine, and as long as you are following his cues, I believe it is the best way to feed your baby.
Learn more about this author, Emmy Daniels.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
On demand
Created on: February 14, 2009
Being the mother of eight children, all of whom were breast-fed with supplemented bottle feeding when needed, I can tell you that feeding a baby on demand will almost always result in a most predictable schedule all by its self. And that will almost always fall somewhere between a three to four-hour feeding schedule.
When a new baby is set on a timed feeding schedule, you will find there will be a lot of crying when your baby is hungry and the clock is telling you that it's not time to feed your baby yet, Your baby's tummy and the clock are not attuned with one another. The hunger pangs that your baby feels are very real, you may find the anxiety you may experience due to your baby's hunger cry to be uncomfortable for you.
In the early weeks of life a baby will have something of an unpredictable eating and sleeping habit, and understandably so after all life outside the womb is quite a transition. For your baby's digestive system to learn to digest breast milk, and if choose to, or need to use baby formula will take a little while. You may find that during some feedings that your baby is satisfied with a small amount of formula, or a seemingly short time at the breast, and though you try you simply can't get you your little one to take any more of their feeding, and that's fine, all that it means is that your baby will probably wake a little sooner for the next feeding, and then you will find that sometime your little one will nurse at the breast a little longer, or maybe drink an ounce more of formula for another feeding, and may be sleeping a little longer before the next feeding.
As the days and weeks pass you will find that your baby's feeding times have began to set a predicable feeding schedule naturally, and your baby's appetite has increased with each passing week, if you have made the transition to just breast feed your baby without baby formula, you will find that you now you are making a lot more breast milk, and your breast become full with milk right around feeding time, which usually is around every three or four hours. After a few months of the feedings falling around every four hours or so you may find that your growing baby is satisfied with nursing early morning, and before naps, and then again at bed time. You will find a similar feeding schedule if you have chosen formula feeding for your baby.
As your little one grows you will be introducing baby cereal, and then baby foods at a steady rate, and you will find that your little one now pretty much eats on a schedule that the family enjoys together. You may find yourself wondering where has the time gone. All to soon those early weeks and months have passed, it's a very special and loving time in your life, enjoy each and every day, the memories will live forever in your heart
Learn more about this author, Sondra Gomez.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.