Home > Education > Primary School > Reading & Writing Skills
Results so far:
| Whole | 44% | 432 votes | Total: 978 votes | |
| Phonics | 56% | 546 votes |
Whole
Created on: December 24, 2007
Phonics is a study of the component parts of words and the sounds made by letters in combination with
Created on: April 25, 2008 Last Updated: March 08, 2012
In a perfect world, each child would learn to read by the method that was best suited to him. Whatever
Created on: April 28, 2010
One telling example of cognitive development versus demonstrated ability occurred when a proud father
Created on: August 30, 2008
Phonics may be a wonderful way to teach a child the correct sounds for letters and letter combinations;
Created on: September 01, 2009 Last Updated: December 17, 2009
I chose to write for whole language as a wonderful way to teach reading. I have to say from the start
Created on: September 15, 2009 Last Updated: September 19, 2009
When my choice came down to an either or situation, I chose the Whole side. My reason for the choice
by Heath Sawyer
Created on: August 13, 2008
I remember when whole language learning was first introduced; I remember it vividly because it was being
Created on: February 12, 2009
The age old argument of whole language versus phonics is outdated and obsolete. Surely people have realised
by K. Russell
Created on: December 03, 2008
Language doesn't exist in isolation, nor should it be taught as a series of independent, isolated sounds.
by Terry Booth
Created on: August 28, 2007
I taught my son to read by the time he was four. Some years later, I taught my granddaughter to read
Created on: February 07, 2008
One of my fantasies is to have Antonio Banderas whisper sweet nothings in my ear. "Quiero pollo para
by Janet Abbey
Created on: April 17, 2008
Even here the media frame of choosing sides displays its face. Thinking in either/or is limiting to
Created on: August 29, 2007
When I went to school in the 1940s and 1950 we were taught to read and spell by whole worlds, we learned
Created on: September 08, 2007
Phonics alphabets are a waste of time. Sure, they are meant to be logical and consistent, but, they
by T.C Leonard
Created on: August 23, 2007
Whole language is a tried and true method of teaching reading; it dates back around many generations
by Tom Parsons
Created on: October 29, 2007
After spending ten years teaching junior high and high school English classes, I believe that teaching
by Virginia
Created on: August 29, 2007
I learnt English as a foreign language in a small town school in India. The current boom in Business
Created on: August 28, 2007
If the English language were fair, fish would be spelled ghoti: gh as in "rough," o as in "women," and
Created on: September 08, 2007
When it comes to learning English, a combination of whole language and phonics will work best. As the
Created on: September 19, 2007
Whole or Phonics? This topic does not offer what I am convinced is the correct answer: Both! Like the
Phonics
Created on: September 05, 2007
In spite of literacy specialists, computers, standardized testing and other innovations, there is still
Created on: October 23, 2010
Whole language, an approach to reading where children learn to read by memorizing text, is ineffective
by Schneider
Created on: July 29, 2007 Last Updated: August 16, 2007
Quite honestly, the question, "Which is a better way to teach children to read: Whole language or phonics?"
by jenlyn
Created on: December 03, 2008
Have you ever watched expectant parents? Often, they can be seen talking to the unborn child as they
by Abbi Sharp
Created on: April 19, 2008
The question "Which is a better way to teach children to read: Whole language or phonics?" is an argument
Created on: August 30, 2007 Last Updated: December 30, 2011
First, let me say that teaching reading should respect the needs of the individual child, and a combination
Created on: January 19, 2009
Recent columns and letters in my local paper have wondered why Americans don't read well or often.
There's
by Carol Natoli
Created on: April 13, 2008 Last Updated: November 27, 2010
Imagine going to a foreign country and seeing letter as part of words that mean nothing to you because
by Sparx
Created on: January 08, 2008
As a parent volunteer within the school system, I saw first hand phonics vs. whole language learning.
Phonics
by Kathy Myers
Created on: September 04, 2009
Phonics, the Best Reading Instruction
Phonics instruction is essential if students are to become excellent
by Joseph Malek
Created on: August 28, 2007 Last Updated: April 28, 2009
The use of phonics is the best method to teach young people how to read. Children learn the symbols
Created on: March 02, 2009 Last Updated: March 09, 2009
I voted phonics, simply because the question asked for, an either/or answer. Learning to read requires
by L Young
Created on: September 12, 2010
by Donald Moore
Created on: August 28, 2007
Whole language reading is somewhat akin to teaching a parrot to say "Polly want a cracker." Even if
Created on: September 07, 2007
Language is built upon a small collection of basic sounds known as phonemes, from which the word "phonics"
by Betty Rodman
Created on: August 30, 2007
I had seven children. They all learned to read before kindergarten. The earliest was 18 months. I taught
Created on: March 25, 2008
Phonics is a widely used method of teaching children to read. It differs greatly from the method of
by Erin Yorke
Created on: July 12, 2007 Last Updated: August 16, 2007
Whole language helps kids see words in a context, thereby increases their understanding of words, but
by Gena Nelson
Created on: August 28, 2007
Both are important to a real knowledge of reading, but phonics instruction equips readers to attack
Join the Debate now.
Write your point of view.