Results so far:
| Yes | 43% | 47 votes | Total: 109 votes | |
| No | 57% | 62 votes |
by Chase Kell
If you think about the present state of the New York Knicks, it is hard to think of anything as a "good idea." Is it a good idea to continue to employ a head coach in need of a ...read more
by Art Vandelay
On paper, the addition of Zach Randolph to the Knicks might look like a good idea. The problem is that it looks like a good idea in the same sense that adding Stephon Marbury, ...read more
by Tj Fife
I really do not understand what goes on in the head of Knicks General Manager. He needs to take his headphones off, stop listening the "Thuggish Ruggish Bone" by bone thugs in h...read more
As I watched the proceedings on Draft day last June, all the New Yok faithful, including current Knick David Lee, applauding and cheering the announcement that the knickerbocker...read more
by Eric Gilmore
To me as an uneducated mixed 24 year old out in Missouri this is an epic mistake. Zach Randolph playing for the New York Knicks is a bad idea. It troubles me to know that ther...read more
Looking at this deal strictly in a vacuum, this was an absolute steal for the New York Knicks. They attained a dominant-type power forward in a conference devoid of them. All th...read more
Randolph to the Knicks is another example of Isiah Thomas running a team that looks more like a fantasy league roster than an NBA caliber squad. Randolph is arguably the best in...read more
Getting a 23-10 power forward (points and rebounds, respectively) surely isn't a bad idea. He's a scoring machine who scored 40 or more points thrice last season. Added 30 or...read more
Amidst the recent controversies surrounding the New York Knicks, which involve a sexual harassment lawsuit against president of basketball operations/head coach Isiah Thomas and...read more
by Seth Newton
Being a former Knick fan (i.e. the Ewing, Oakley, Starks era), it was exciting to see the team head down a different road. Any change from their current situation, minus sellin...read more
by Derek Flack
The NBA Draft 2007 in New York City involved a huge deal between the New York Knicks and the Portland Trailblazers. In this trade the Knicks picked up the ticking time ...read more
by Wordsleuth
Is Zach Randolph playing for the New York Kincks a bad idea? How about no. Isaiah Thomas took on very little risk getting Zach Randolph from the Portland Trailblazers. He...read more
by Sanat Daga
Zack Randolph coming to the New York Knicks was a very wise decision for the Knicks organization. It really provides them with the consistent scorer they needed, especially in ...read more
by Noel Lora
I think Zach Randolph is a great pick up for the knicks. For one he brings an inside presence that was much needed , plus he can also hit jumpers from the perimeter. He's a grea...read more

