Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Politics, News & Issues   >

Basketball

Get a Widget for this title

Is Zach Randolph playing for the New York Knicks a bad idea?

Results so far:

Yes
46% 59 votes Total: 129 votes
No
54% 70 votes
Yes

It has seemed like an era from 2001-2002.

Michigan State sophomore, Zach Randolph entered the NBA Draft as Portland's first round, lottery pick. He and Jason Richardson led their vaunted Spartans into a lengthy, NCAA tournament run in March. They failed to reach the pinnacle as champions. But, the duo spearheaded an athletic squad with high-flying dunks, physical post play and much-needed leadership.

For five seasons, (some injury-filled) he averaged over 18 points and nine rebounds a game. However, he followed the path of that draft's rising superstars. He chose to ask for a king's ransom. He had Trailblazers' owner, Paul Allen throwing millions to keep him. After signing an infamous, $14 million a year contract, Randolph's hunger for notoriety stopped.

While as a Spartan, he played with a massive "chip" on his shoulder. He played ferociously for his hunter green. He defended and rebounded with reckless abandon for coach Tom Izzo and his teammates. However, he obtained riches beyond his Flint, Michigan college years. He got "fat" off his maxed-out contract. He scored and rebounded for his numbers and NBA fantasy owners only. He stopped defending. His Trailblazers stopped winning.

Randolph's selfish play epitomized the selfish attitude in the locker room. Even, bringing Scottie Pippen out of retirement failed to make headway on the youthful Trailblazers. They lost games badly. They failed to make the playoffs after a decade-plus long run with former coach, Rick Adelman. To add, Randolph had problems off the court with a DUI arrest and other misdemeanor arrests.

Allen shipped off Randolph to the Big Apple. With that, he gained a team-first mentality. Coach Nate McMillian put his squad into the hands of all-world, two-guard, Brandon Roy. The former, Washington Huskies standout took ownership of an electic and exciting mix which included the likes of LaMarcus Aldridge (LSU), Travis Outlaw, Martell Webster, Qntel Woods and Steve Blake.

During last season, Randolph and Roy got into a verbal altercation. McMillan chose his unselfish, "stat-stuffing" guard over an all-star caliber center/power forward. The cleared cap room allowed for Portland to gain a #1 pick in the 2007 draft. It also removed a potential "cancer" on a fragile team. Randolph refused to buy into the team-first approach. He often battled with the coach on being the team's first, scoring option. As a big man, he did nothing for the Trailblazers' offensive capabilities. For someone averaging almost 20 points and 10 boards a game, Randolph had the fewest assists (less than 2) per game.

Since 2000, the Knicks' franchise proved to be a dumping ground for NBA's overblown contracts. Randolph's acquisition joined the likes of the maligned journeyman, Tim Thomas, former, Maryland star, Steve "Stevie Franchise" Francis, Jalen Rose and most recently, the mercurial Stephon "Starbury" Marbury. Madison Square Garden looked more like a boring, three-ring circus than home to a pro basketball team. They overpaid and bought out the contracts of their former coaches, Larry Brown and Isiah Thomas. During a once, affluent economy, New York showed an example of careless over-spending.

Randol ph just became the icing on a cake too rich to swallow.

Learn more about this author, Marcus Brooks.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

Amidst the recent controversies surrounding the New York Knicks, which involve a sexual harassment lawsuit against president of basketball operations/head coach Isiah Thomas and statements made by Stephon Marbury defending Michael Vick for promoting illegal dog-fighting, the acquisition of Zach Randolph on June 28th, 2007 appeared quite tame in the eyes of basketball fans. However, with Randolph's off-the-court history of underage drinking, sexual assault complaints, and scuffles with his own teammates, was acquiring the power forward from the Portland Trail Blazers a smart decision by a Knicks team already embroiled in controversy?

Solely examining Randolph's performance on-the-court, which consists of mid-range jump shots and left-handed post moves, I would have to disagree with the Knicks' acquisition of the 2003-04 NBA's Most Improved Player.

Why?

With a team like the New York Knicks, who have struggled with ball movement and overall team motivation in the past, trading for Zach Randolph seems like a step in the wrong direction. Sure, Randolph has proven to be a dominating scorer in previous seasons, averaging 23.7 points per game in 2006-07, but this came on a struggling team that won a total of 21 games only a year prior. Furthermore, Randolph has never been a strong defender in the low post, a presence the Knicks severely lack because of Eddy Curry's inconsistent front-court play.

Having Randolph and Curry share the floor will be difficult, as in several ways, they represent the same player one who struggles to perform consistently on defense, while also stopping any flow on offense when in possession of the basketball, due to their inability to find the open man.

I decided to give Randolph the benefit of the doubt before taking a side, as a clean slate is usually given when a player joins a new team. However, now almost midway into the season and the Knicks still struggling to play team-oriented basketball, Randolph has shown only what he did in Portland he can put the ball in the basket. Choosing to play one-on-one basketball instead of letting the offense come to him, Randolph's habit of settling for poor jump shots often disrupts any fluidity the Knicks have on offense. Unfortunately, the Knicks need far more from him and the rest of the team if they want to show any improvement this season. If Thomas continues to use Randolph and Curry in the front-court together, the Knicks will be hurt by any team with a decent interior presence.

The only positive in Randolph's brief tenure with the Knicks has been an absence in the off-the-court problems that soured his time in Portland. However, with all of the recent controversy surrounding the Knickerbocker franchise, perhaps a scandal would be the only way Randolph and New York will ever make a perfect fit.

Learn more about this author, Niko Krommydas.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA