Search Helium

Home > Politics, News & Issues > News > People in the News

Will Michael Moore be remembered for his contributions as a film-maker or as a political activist?

Results so far:

Politics
63% 225 votes Total: 355 votes
Films
37% 130 votes

Politics

by David Elder

Created on: March 02, 2008

Michael Moore is a film maker, the author of several books, and a political activist, who has transformed the term "Question Authority" into his own personal art form. For a majority of Americans, Michael Moore is an irritation, an insult to hallowed institutions, and a misguided rebel who finds fault with our government at every turn. For these reasons, he will be remembered more as a political activist than as a filmmaker. Only time will tell if his books will be his crowning achievement.

Michael Moore is either lauded as a visionary or reviled as a traitor. Regardless of his affect on those who read his books or watch his films, he fulfills his role as agitator admirably. It may be a combination of his scraggly appearance, his weight, and his overbearing confidence in his mission to uncover real and imagined conspiracies that makes him a lightning rod for polarity. Whether he's hated or hailed, it's impossible not to have an opinion of Michael Moore.

In his first film "Roger and Me" Mr. Moore chronicles the demise of Flint Michigan through the loss of automotive jobs at General Motors. As with all of his subsequent documentaries, Michael mixes humor with serious accusations that show in stark reality, the damaging effects on Middle America caused by corporate greed. True to his "in your face" style of journalism; Michael tries to get an interview with Roger Smith, the CEO of GM, with hysterical results.

Following the same general theme, Moore's film "The Big One" shines a light on the Nike Corporation and their propensity for sweatshop manufacturing overseas, and whom he contends ignores and even encourages human rights violations. Moore's interviews with the CEO of Nike, Phil Knight, garnered some priceless responses that eventually led to improved conditions at Nike's plants.

The film "Bowling for Columbine" decried the proliferation of guns in America, and the ease with which they could be obtained. Michael's efforts were rewarded with an Oscar, the unending enmity of the NRA. Mr. Moore's interview with the spokesman and president of the NRA, Charlton Heston, showed his lack of respect as he belittled one of America's favorite icons. The treatment of Mr. Heston at the hands of Michael Moore may have been the turning point for conservative America in their utter dislike of the filmmaker.

In his most controversial film to date, "Fahrenheit 9/11" Michael Moore took aim at President Bush and his administration for the handling of the aftermath of the tragedy on September 11th, 2001, and the subsequent war in Iraq. Strong business ties between the Bush family and Saudi Arabian Sheiks were detailed in this movie, which alienated a large portion of the American public. By this time it became apparent that no one in political office or business leadership wanted to talk to Michael Moore.

His latest film, "Sicko" is an indictment of the health care industry in America. The film follows the plight of ordinary American citizens who are trying to obtain medical care, and concludes that an alternative system is needed which caters more to the patient than a conglomeration of profit minded medical institutions and insurance companies.

Michael Moore, for better or worse, has become the conscience of America. His dogged desire to uncover governmental corruption and incompetence is at the core of our strength as a nation. His mission to show the deleterious effects of outsourcing, and the horror of human rights violations should be applauded. The mixture of humor that plays like a sardonic tune through all of his films helps to ease the burden of the painful introspection of our nation.

There are those who find him odious and needlessly irreverent, shocked at the temerity of anyone who would insult our President. American business leaders wish he would simply go away, seeing him more as a pain in the backside than the quixotic crusader envisioned by his supporters.

Without men and women like Michael Moore, our nation could be lulled into complacency. If he overreaches at times, we will excuse his minor lapse, remembering that we need the occasional hard look in the mirror. His lack of respect for convention forces us to consider that which we may have been ignoring.

We will look forward to his newest documentary, and delight at those who squirm at his approach. The value of someone like Mr. Moore cannot be overstated in a world of respectful conformity. He dares to challenge that comfortable conventionality with his political activism, for which he will always be remembered.

http://www.michaelmoore.com/books-films/index.php

Learn more about this author, David Elder.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Films

by Paul Schingle

Created on: July 18, 2008

While I may agree with Michael Moore on most of his political views, I don't necessarily see him as a great spokesman for particular causes-except when he lets his film-making do the talking for him. This is a tough debate to take sides on. In the end, Michael Moore may well wish to be remembered for his political activism, but it is in the forum of his film-making that he makes the most impact. Both may be important in his life, but his films will be what is most remembered about Michael Moore.

I've seen Michael Moore speak and I often agree with what he has to say, but anything he can say in a speech bashing George W. is amplified tenfold by watching "Fahrenheit 9-11." As many Hollywood types are, Michael Moore is very politically outspoken. This is all fine and dandy, but it's his work as an artist that really grabs one's attention. Making movies is where Michael Moore shines best. Using his films as a forum for political debate is just a bonus. Not many people can make documentaries with the impact of a "Bowling for Columbine" or a "Fahrenheit 9-11" but Michael Moore has done it beautifully. These contributions will always be remembered.

I guess I don't see why the two have to be mutually exclusive. The question should probably be worded, "Will Michael Moore be remembered MORE for his contributions..." There can be no doubt that Michael Moore is a political activist. His stances on Iraq, post 9-11 America and white-collar America are well understood. But, he displays his views best when he presents them on film. His movies are made with an obvious slant, but he will always try to present as fair an argument as he can. And the films themselves are usually brilliantly done. With this in mind, I'll always think of his film-making ahead of his speechifying. For Michael Moore, film is his conduit for speech. Like a good non-fiction writer, documentary film is how Michael Moore best presents his views.

Call me a sucker for good art, but between the two, I think Michael Moore will always be remembered more for his films than his political activism. The two are definitely intertwined, but it's his work as a film-maker that separates him from the rest. A lot of people in Hollywood are politically active and most of them have something to say publicly. But, as is often the case, Michael Moore makes the case for his causes with much greater impact with his art-his film-making-than with his speech-making.

Learn more about this author, Paul Schingle.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA