Business >
International Business & Trade
Get a Widget for this title
RSS FeedIs it safe to continue to import Chinese food products?
Results so far:
| No | 65% | 264 votes | Total: 404 votes | |
| Yes | 35% | 140 votes |
No
Write now
Print
Invite a writer™
Add to FavoritesMelamine has recently been in the news for being found in food products coming from China. Why is it there? What is it used for? And what can it possibly do to harm us? These are some of the questions I had recently as I heard the news reports about Baby Milk recalls and more recently Halloween candy in the form of pirate coins.
According to Wikipedia, Melamine is an organic base and a trimer of cyanamide. Melamine by its self is not toxic but when mixed with cyanuric acid it becomes toxic.
So, why is it used in digestible products? It is added to raise the level of protein in baby formula milk. Formula milk had not been tested until recently for levels of Melamine because it was not assumed to be present in the product.
According to the MSDA sheet on Melamine, it is harmful if swallowed, inhaled or absorbed through the skin. Chronic exposure may cause cancer or reproductive damage. It is an eye, skin and respiratory irritant.
About a year ago, Melamine was found in pet food and blamed for killing thousands of cats and dogs and many recalled pet food products. And yet a year later, we find it in baby formula. Ice cream produced by Yili, an Olympic sponsor, has shown the presence of Melamine.
What does exposure to Melamine cause? Exposure can lead to bladder or kidney stones, bladder cancer, and kidney failure. We know this to be true from pure Melamine, but we don't know what contaminants were added to the Melamine used. What affects do these contaminants cause? For companies who care little about the end user by putting Melamine into their consumable product, can we really trust the purity of the Melamine they used?
The list of recalled items, which are mainly Chinese versions of these products, have very common names. The list is broader than we have been lead to expect in the US. Items like Chinese made cheesecake, cookies from the Netherlands, Mr. Brown coffee products, Cadbury, Ritz snacks, Chinese candy, Dove chocolates, Dreyers cake mix, Oreo wafer sticks, M&Ms, Snickers, and the list goes on. I do want to reiterate that these products found with Melamine were Chinese made products not their counterparts made elsewhere.
Some of these items have found their way to US store shelves. Most recently found in Halloween candy, Sherwood Brands Pirate's Gold Milk Chocolate Coins manufactured in China have tested positive by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. These products have been found in Costco and many dollar and bulk type stores in the US.
If you are concerned about any product contents you can double check the FDA website for a list of product warnings. These can be found at the following website: http://www.fda.gov/o c/opacom/hottopics/m elamine.html#warning s
Resources:
http://ww w.sciencebase.com
htt p://www.wilipedia.co m
http://www.fda.gov
Learn more about this author, Janet Trieschman.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Yes
Ultimately it's as safe to continue to import Chinese food products as it is to import food from any country, provided that adequate food checks are carried out by relevant authorities and consumers are fully informed as to the contents. In essence, it is not a particular country that should be singled out but rather the quality of food emanating from a specific manufacturer, irrespective of country of origin.
In addition to food checks, what is also essential is that the labeling laws of the host country are fully complied with and accurately specify the contents and nutritional information, such as percentage of fat by type, etc.
These tests should be mandatory and carried out in the country of destination, with costs borne by the exporter or importer. Confiscation and other appropriate penalties should feature as part of a program for offending importers as this will encourage honesty and compliance. Furthermore, it should be mandatory for the name of importers to feature on packs and details of products that fail inspection should be publicized, together with the offending importer's name.
In this way safeguards are built in and people have the benefit of choice, within the confines of food products that have exceeded basic legal requirements.
Having provided food for thought, I can now give thought for food and look forward to getting stuck into some authentic chop suey, optimistically without MSG.
Even if it did have the MSG would it be any worse than the fatty and artery blocking fast foods that have emanated from the red, white and blue and which,in a globalized world, have made millions of fast food addicts obese and unhealthy around the globe?
Why this focussing on Peking? It's Chinese to me!
Learn more about this author, Alan Kaplan.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Difference of opinion? Debate now.
- International Business & Trade
- Outsourcing causes more problems than cures for a company
- Has globalization hurt America's workers?
- Who is right in the Groupe Danone beverage company battle between French and Chinese entrepreneurs?
- From conflicts in China to buying US Kraft foods, is the French Groupe Danone leading France toward a more competitive role in international trade?
- Should China face financial penalties for unfair export practices?
